What type of appraisal would a panel of judges use to assess an artistic gymnastics routine? (A) Check-list (B) Objective assessment (C) Personal criteria (D) Prescribed criteria - HSC - SSCE Personal Development and Physical Education - Question 14 - 2002 - Paper 1

A panel of judges assessing an artistic gymnastics routine would typically use a method that ensures consistency and fairness in evaluation. The most suitable option here is Prescribed criteria (D).

Rationale:

• Prescribed criteria refer to standardized guidelines that judges must follow when evaluating performances. This allows for objective comparisons between different routines and helps ensure that all athletes are judged according to the same standards.
• In artistic gymnastics, judges rely on detailed scoring systems that outline specific elements to evaluate, ensuring that every gymnast is assessed on a level playing field.

Why Other Options Are Less Suitable:

• Check-list (A): While this may be useful for monitoring specific elements, it doesn’t provide a comprehensive assessment framework.
• Objective assessment (B): This term is more general and could apply to various criteria; it isn’t specific enough to describe the structured nature of how gymnastics is judged.
• Personal criteria (C): This could lead to subjective judgments based on individual preferences rather than a standardized evaluation process.