Photo AI
'The Victorian Parliament represents all Victorian people and everyone in Victoria has access to our legal system.' Discuss the extent to which you agree with this statement. - VCE - SSCE Legal Studies - Question 10 - 2017 - Paper 1
Question 10
'The Victorian Parliament represents all Victorian people and everyone in Victoria has access to our legal system.' Discuss the extent to which you agree with this ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:'The Victorian Parliament represents all Victorian people and everyone in Victoria has access to our legal system.' Discuss the extent to which you agree with this statement. - VCE - SSCE Legal Studies - Question 10 - 2017 - Paper 1
Step 1
Discuss the statement: 'The Victorian Parliament represents all Victorian people'
Answer
The statement highlights the representative nature of the Victorian Parliament. While the Parliament is elected by the people, it may not fully represent the diverse views and needs of all Victorian citizens. Conflicting perspectives within society can lead to differing opinions on what representation means. For instance, in matters of law and policy, there are often significant disparities in interests among different groups, which may not result in a single representation of all citizens.
Moreover, majority representation can lead to the neglect of minority views, as parliament tends to adopt the positions of the majority. The concept of hostile upper houses complicates this further, as such bodies may impose additional resistance to proposed laws, thereby not reflecting the will of the people.
Additionally, constitutional restrictions may limit the Parliament's ability to address certain community concerns, making it difficult for them to represent everyone effectively.
Step 2
Discuss the statement: 'everyone in Victoria has access to our legal system'
Answer
Access to the legal system is another critical component of this statement. While Victoria's legal system includes various avenues for resolving disputes — such as VCAT and the court system — several barriers hinder equitable access. For instance, geographical location can significantly influence an individual's ability to engage with the legal system, especially in rural areas where legal services may be limited.
Moreover, the complexity of legal processes can deter individuals from seeking justice, particularly those lacking a thorough understanding of the law. Specific groups, including new migrants and young people, may find it especially challenging to navigate legal frameworks due to language barriers or lack of awareness of their rights.
Furthermore, despite efforts to increase access through alternative dispute resolution methods, many individuals still find themselves unable to resolve conflicts without significant financial burdens. Overall, while systems exist, true equitable access often remains elusive for many Victorians.