Photo AI
Using Figure 4 and your own knowledge, assess the usefulness of sources such as this in representing a place - AQA - A-Level Geography - Question 2 - 2019 - Paper 2
Question 2
Using Figure 4 and your own knowledge, assess the usefulness of sources such as this in representing a place. Figure 4 shows lyrics from 'Wickerman', a song about S... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Using Figure 4 and your own knowledge, assess the usefulness of sources such as this in representing a place - AQA - A-Level Geography - Question 2 - 2019 - Paper 2
Step 1
AO1 - Assessing the Usefulness of Qualitative Sources
Answer
Qualitative sources like song lyrics can provide insight into the lived experiences and emotions associated with a place. In the case of 'Wickerman' by Pulp, the lyrics capture a sense of identity and social issues in Sheffield, such as de-industrialization. However, while they evoke strong feelings and imagery, these interpretations are subjective and may not represent the entire demographic or physical reality of Sheffield.
Step 2
AO2 - Application to the Situation
Answer
Figure 4 represents Sheffield by illustrating themes of decay and transformation, influenced by historical context. The lyrics may suggest that the place has suffered due to past industrial practices, which aligns with broader narratives of urban decline. Additionally, such songs can evoke nostalgia and personal memories that resonate with listeners, but they could also overlook other critical aspects like ongoing urban development and community rebuilding.
Step 3
Evaluation of Sources
Answer
Evaluating the usefulness of 'Wickerman' requires considering both its emotional impact and its limitations. While the song may evoke strong images and experiences of Sheffield, it lacks comprehensive data or factual representation. Lyrics like those in 'Dirty Old Town' can offer reflections on specific areas, but they do not substitute for empirical studies or diverse perspectives on the evolving nature of urban places.