Photo AI

Lizzie is sat securely on a wooden sledge - AQA - A-Level Maths Pure - Question 17 - 2019 - Paper 2

Question icon

Question 17

Lizzie-is-sat-securely-on-a-wooden-sledge-AQA-A-Level Maths Pure-Question 17-2019-Paper 2.png

Lizzie is sat securely on a wooden sledge. The combined mass of Lizzie and the sledge is $M$ kilograms. The sledge is being pulled forward in a straight line along... show full transcript

Worked Solution & Example Answer:Lizzie is sat securely on a wooden sledge - AQA - A-Level Maths Pure - Question 17 - 2019 - Paper 2

Step 1

Show that T = \frac{M(a + \mu g)}{\cos \theta + \mu \sin \theta}

96%

114 rated

Answer

To derive the expression for tension TT, we need to apply Newton's second law in horizontal and vertical directions.

1. Resolving Forces Vertically:
In the vertical direction, the forces acting are the weight of Lizzie and the sledge (MgMg) and the vertical component of the tension (TsinθT\sin \theta). The normal reaction force RR acts upward:

R+Tsinθ=MgR + T\sin \theta = Mg
=> R=MgTsinθR = Mg - T\sin \theta.

2. Resolving Forces Horizontally:
In the horizontal direction, the only horizontal forces are the horizontal component of the tension (TcosθT\cos \theta) and the frictional force (μR\mu R). Using Newton's second law for motion in the horizontal direction:

TcosθμR=MaT\cos \theta - \mu R = Ma

3. Replacing R:
Substituting for RR from the vertical resolution:

Tcosθμ(MgTsinθ)=MaT\cos \theta - \mu (Mg - T\sin \theta) = Ma

4. Rearranging the Equation:
This expands to:

TcosθμMg+μTsinθ=MaT\cos \theta - \mu Mg + \mu T\sin \theta = Ma

Rearranging gives:

T(cosθ+μsinθ)=Ma+μMgT (\cos \theta + \mu \sin \theta) = Ma + \mu Mg

5. Final Expression for T:
Dividing the entire equation by (cosθ+μsinθ)(\cos \theta + \mu \sin \theta) leads to:

T=M(a+μg)cosθ+μsinθT = \frac{M(a + \mu g)}{\cos \theta + \mu \sin \theta}.

Step 2

Explain why her value for \mu may be incorrect.

99%

104 rated

Answer

When M=30M = 30, θ=30\theta = 30^{\circ}, and T=40T = 40, the sledge is stated to remain at rest. However, the relationship derived assumes that all the forces are acting at their limiting values of friction.

1. Friction is not at Limiting Value:
Since the sledge is at rest, the friction between the sledge and the surface could be static rather than kinetic. The value of μ\mu obtained from the relationship assumes that the friction force FSF_S is at its limiting value, which may not be the case.

2. Factors influencing Friction:
The coefficient of friction can vary based on factors such as surface roughness and wear. If the surface is not uniformly rough or there is some presence of other materials, it could affect the actual value of μ\mu. Thus, the value calculated under theoretical assumptions may not reflect real-world conditions precisely.

3. Possible Misalignment:
Additionally, if the angle θ\theta is measured inaccurately or if the acceleration is not exactly 00, it can lead to a calculation that does not represent the actual friction coefficient.

Join the A-Level students using SimpleStudy...

97% of Students

Report Improved Results

98% of Students

Recommend to friends

100,000+

Students Supported

1 Million+

Questions answered

;