Photo AI
Focus this part of your answer on the second part of the source, from line 19 to the end - AQA - GCSE English Language - Question 4 - 2022 - Paper 1
Question 4
Focus this part of your answer on the second part of the source, from line 19 to the end. A student said, "In this part of the story, Juana’s reaction to the danger... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Focus this part of your answer on the second part of the source, from line 19 to the end - AQA - GCSE English Language - Question 4 - 2022 - Paper 1
Step 1
consider Juana’s and Kino’s reactions to the danger facing their baby
Answer
In the story, both Juana and Kino exhibit intense concern for their baby's safety, yet their responses differ significantly. Juana responds instinctively and tends to prioritize the immediate safety of their child over all else. Her actions are driven by maternal instincts; for instance, when she seeks to remove the scorpion's poison from the baby, this reflects her immediate desire to protect her child before any external threats are even fully addressed.
In contrast, Kino's reaction is more calculated yet ultimately misguided. He tends to externalize the threat, focusing on avenging the perceived danger instead of addressing the direct needs of the child. His actions include confronting the danger head-on, such as when he seeks to hunt down the scorpion, suggesting a more aggressive stance that, while it reflects his protective instincts, often leads to inaction regarding the baby’s safety.
Step 2
evaluate how the writer presents Juana’s and Kino’s different reactions
Answer
The writer portrays Juana as more nurturing and instinctive, employing imagery that highlights her desperation and maternal instincts. For example, her reaction to suck the poison from the baby is depicted as both selfless and urgent. This contrasts with Kino, who is presented through more aggressive and conflicted imagery. The writer uses metaphors such as describing Kino's reaction to the scorpion as that of an 'aggressive hunter,' indicating a more flawed approach to protection.
Furthermore, the juxtaposition between Kino’s delayed response due to rage and Juana’s immediate actions underscores the significance of their different approaches to parenting. This narrative choice reflects on the theme of protective instincts and illustrates the contrasting roles the characters embody.
Step 3
support your response with references to the text
Answer
In the narrative, Juana exemplifies her protective role when she states that she will ‘suck the poison’ from the baby, indicating her immediate action in critical situations. This act exemplifies her readiness to take risks for her child’s safety. Conversely, when Kino comes face to face with the source of danger, his initial reaction is rooted in anger and revenge, reflecting a failure to prioritize the immediate health of his child. His contemplations may serve to strengthen the storyline but often distract him from the pressing needs of both Juana and the baby.
Moreover, the dialogue 'Go to get the doctor' reinforced by Kino’s insistence contrasts starkly with Juana's selfless motives, illustrating the disconnect in their reactions to the same situation. This literary device effectively highlights the theme of differing parental instincts, framing Juana as the more immediate protector.