Photo AI
How far does Russell present Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons as very different kinds of mother in Blood Brothers? Write about: - what Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons say and do - how far Russell presents Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons as very different kinds of mother. - AQA - GCSE English Literature - Question 3 - 2023 - Paper 2
Question 3
How far does Russell present Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons as very different kinds of mother in Blood Brothers? Write about: - what Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons say a... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:How far does Russell present Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons as very different kinds of mother in Blood Brothers? Write about: - what Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons say and do - how far Russell presents Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons as very different kinds of mother. - AQA - GCSE English Literature - Question 3 - 2023 - Paper 2
Step 1
what Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons say and do
Answer
Mrs Johnstone is portrayed as a nurturing and loving mother who prioritizes her children above all else, despite her challenging circumstances. For instance, her character often expresses her love through her actions, such as working multiple jobs and making sacrifices for her children's well-being. She uses endearing language, demonstrating a deep emotional bond with them.
In contrast, Mrs Lyons exhibits a more controlling and possessive demeanor towards her children. Her statements reveal her desire to maintain a facade of superiority and control, as she'd rather shield her son, Edward, from the realities of their social class and the world outside. Unlike Mrs Johnstone, who is more open about her struggles, Mrs Lyons often hides her emotions behind a façade of wealth and stability.
Step 2
how far Russell presents Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons as very different kinds of mother
Answer
Russell presents a stark contrast between Mrs Johnstone and Mrs Lyons, emphasizing the impact of social class and individual circumstances on motherhood. Mrs Johnstone’s character represents the working class, filled with warmth and devotion, which often leads to heartbreak due to external pressures. Her maternal instincts shine through her sacrifices and patience, making her a relatable figure to the audience.
On the other hand, Mrs Lyons embodies the privilege and insecurity of the upper class. Her need to control Edward stems from her background and societal expectations, leading her to adopt a more rigid parenting style. Russell juxtaposes these two mothers to highlight how socio-economic factors shape their identities and parenting methods. Ultimately, the differences underscore the play’s commentary on class disparity and the often misguided notions of motherhood.