Study Source A in the Sources Booklet - AQA - GCSE History - Question 1 - 2020 - Paper 1

To evaluate the usefulness of Source A, we must analyze both the content and provenance of the source.

Content Evaluation

Source A may provide insights into the arguments surrounding women's suffrage, possibly presenting viewpoints from various stakeholders such as suffragists and opponents. If it highlights the methods of campaigning, public perception, or specific events related to the votes for women movement, it could be deemed quite useful.

For example, if Source A includes quotes from prominent suffragists or references notable events, this contextual knowledge can greatly enhance our understanding of the period.

Provenance Consideration

Moreover, understanding who created Source A, in what context, and for what purpose is crucial. If the source is from a sympathetic perspective towards women's suffrage, it could provide compelling evidence of the views and strategies used during the suffrage movement. Conversely, if it comes from a critical standpoint, its utility lies in illustrating the opposition faced by suffragists.

In conclusion, Source A is useful for historians as it allows them to analyze the contrasting perspectives on women's votes and helps to contextualize these within the broader suffrage movement. Hence, the source's relevance and reliability depend on its content and the intentions behind its creation.