Photo AI
In this extract, the writer attempts to show different opinions - Edexcel - GCSE English Language - Question 6 - 2019 - Paper 1
Question 6
In this extract, the writer attempts to show different opinions. Evaluate how successfully this is achieved. Support your views with detailed reference to the text.
Worked Solution & Example Answer:In this extract, the writer attempts to show different opinions - Edexcel - GCSE English Language - Question 6 - 2019 - Paper 1
Step 1
Evaluate how successfully the writer shows different opinions
Answer
The writer successfully showcases different opinions by employing a variety of quotations, allowing the voices of the characters to be heard distinctly. For example, the extract begins with several contrasting statements, such as those from William and Kate, who express their enjoyment of their stay. This contrast creates a space for the reader to appreciate varying perspectives.
Moreover, by referencing 'TripAdvisor' multiple times, the writer suggests that these opinions are grounded in real feedback from guests, thereby lending credibility to each viewpoint expressed in the extract.
Step 2
Examine the neutral perspective maintained by the writer
Answer
The writer skillfully maintains a neutral tone throughout the extract by adopting a third-person narrative style. Phrases like 'some TripAdvisor users' highlight the diversity of opinions without assigning personal bias. The use of dispassionate language when describing the criticisms, such as the 'grease-smeared menu', further emphasizes the objective stance taken by the writer.
Step 3
Discuss the use of various quotation techniques
Answer
The extract effectively utilizes direct quotations to suggest positive views while also contrasting them with negative feedback. For instance, while guests report satisfaction, others express disappointment, showcasing a balance in opinions. The writer indicates this variance by stating, 'some travelers were delighted', juxtaposed with 'many feared it would not meet expectations.' This maneuver enriches the article's depth, illustrating that opinions are not just one-dimensional.