In this extract, the writer attempts to show the treatment of Jewish people - Edexcel - GCSE English Language - Question 6 - 2019 - Paper 1

The extract opens by suggesting the writer's consciousness of their Jewish identity, hinting at the precariousness of their situation. This is evident in the phrase ‘as we are Jewish, we emigrated to Holland in 1933,’ signalling both a personal and cultural context that frames their experience.

The description of treatment faced by Jewish people is communicated through a personal lens. The use of first-person narrative engages the reader, establishing a direct connection with the experiences shared. For example, the depiction of restrictive shopping hours reflects societal disdain, emphasizing the limitations imposed on Jewish individuals.

Further development occurs when the writer contrasts factual accounts with personal narratives, enriching the portrayal of the environment. The reference to the diary indicates a deep sense of loss and fear, particularly when discussing the camps. Statements like ‘Westbork sounds terrible’ invite the reader to empathize with the plight of Jewish people, amplifying the emotional weight of the text.

Additionally, the extract’s layering of perspectives provides insight into the writer's emotional and psychological states, which effectively highlights the impact of external prejudices on individual lives. This is particularly poignant in sections detailing feelings of isolation and the attempt to escape persecution.

Ultimately, while the extract successfully conveys a personal account of the Jewish experience during a turbulent time, it does not purport to present a comprehensive historical overview. The references to personal experiences convey a subjective truth rather than a universal narrative regarding the treatment of Jewish people during World War II.