Photo AI
The two texts show the experiences of certain groups of people - Edexcel - GCSE English Language - Question 7 - 2019 - Paper 1
Question 7
The two texts show the experiences of certain groups of people. What similarities do these groups share in these extracts? Use evidence from both texts to suppo... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:The two texts show the experiences of certain groups of people - Edexcel - GCSE English Language - Question 7 - 2019 - Paper 1
Step 1
What similarities do these groups share in these extracts?
Answer
Both groups go about their daily lives under restrictive conditions. In Text 1, the experiences of women reflect on their mundane work lives, while in Text 2, a similar longing for normalcy persists as individuals attempt to navigate their circumstances. Each extract illustrates the detrimental impact of the respective regulations faced by these groups, underscoring their shared sentiments of frustration and sadness concerning their treatment. The references to anti-Jewish laws in Text 2 and restrictions in Text 1 showcase a commonality in the ways these groups face societal obstacles.
Step 2
Compare how the writers of Text 1 and Text 2 present ideas and perspectives about discrimination.
Answer
The texts target different audiences, with Text 1 intended for a broad audience and Text 2 serving as a personal diary. This audience difference shapes the narrative style, where Text 1 offers a third-person perspective while Text 2 is first-person.
Both writers convey their distress about discrimination. Text 1 uses language that depicts the absurdity of their plight, referencing the 'ridiculous' nature of their treatment, while Text 2 explicitly details harsh realities faced. The emotional depth and personal reflections in Text 2 contrast with the observational tone of Text 1.
Furthermore, the writers illustrate individual experiences of discrimination, underscoring both shared and distinct aspects of their struggles. In Text 1, the emotional impact of discrimination is shown through the collective voice, whereas in Text 2, personal anecdotes serve to provide a more intimate perspective. The closing sentiments in both texts highlight a sense of futility and resilience amidst discrimination.