Here is a speed-time graph for a train - Edexcel - GCSE Maths - Question 18 - 2017 - Paper 3
Question 18
Here is a speed-time graph for a train.
(a) Work out an estimate for the distance the train travelled in the first 20 seconds.
Use 4 strips of equal width.
(b) Is ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Here is a speed-time graph for a train - Edexcel - GCSE Maths - Question 18 - 2017 - Paper 3
Step 1
Work out an estimate for the distance the train travelled in the first 20 seconds.
96%
114 rated
Only available for registered users.
Sign up now to view full answer, or log in if you already have an account!
Answer
To estimate the distance travelled by the train, we will use 4 strips of equal width on the speed-time graph.
Determine the width of each strip: The time interval is from 0 to 20 seconds. Given that we are to use 4 strips, each strip will have a width of:
extWidth=420 seconds=5 seconds
Estimate the heights (speeds) for each strip:
For the first strip (0s to 5s): Read the graph at 5 seconds, where speed is approximately 10 m/s.
For the second strip (5s to 10s): Read the graph at 10 seconds, where speed is approximately 15 m/s.
For the third strip (10s to 15s): Read the graph at 15 seconds, where speed is approximately 20 m/s.
For the fourth strip (15s to 20s): Read the graph at 20 seconds, where speed is approximately 25 m/s.
Calculate the area for each strip:
Area of strip 1 = Base × Height = 5s × 10m/s = 50 m
Area of strip 2 = 5s × 15m/s = 75 m
Area of strip 3 = 5s × 20m/s = 100 m
Area of strip 4 = 5s × 25m/s = 125 m
Sum the areas of the strips to find the total distance travelled:
extTotalDistance=50+75+100+125=350 m
Thus, the estimated distance the train travelled in the first 20 seconds is 350 m.
Step 2
Is your answer to (a) an underestimate or an overestimate of the actual distance the train travelled?
99%
104 rated
Only available for registered users.
Sign up now to view full answer, or log in if you already have an account!
Answer
The answer to part (a) is an overestimate of the actual distance the train travelled.
Reason: This estimation method uses rectangles to calculate area. Since the speed of the train increases, the speed-time graph is a convex curve. Therefore, the area under the curve between the speed-time graph and the rectangles will always yield a larger area (distance) compared to the actual area under the curve. This is why our calculated value of 350 m is greater than the actual distance the train travelled in the first 20 seconds.