Photo AI
Study Sources D and E - OCR Gateway - GCSE History - Question 4 - 2020 - Paper 1
Question 4
Study Sources D and E. Which of these sources is more useful to a historian studying the history of Kenilworth Castle between 1100 and 1300?
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Study Sources D and E - OCR Gateway - GCSE History - Question 4 - 2020 - Paper 1
Step 1
Source D Analysis
Answer
Source D can provide critical insights into the architectural development of Kenilworth Castle during the specified period. It may discuss notable features of the castle built in the 12th century, thereby illustrating the evolution of building techniques and historical significance of the site. A historian can extract information about any renovations or events that may have affected the castle's importance within the region.
Step 2
Source E Analysis
Answer
Source E likely offers a narrative regarding historical events related to Kenilworth Castle, including its role in political situations, conflicts, and the residents of the castle. This source may detail events from the 13th century, which the historian can use to contextualize the castle's changing role over time and draw connections to broader historical themes.
Step 3
Comparison of Sources
Answer
When comparing the two sources, the historian must evaluate which offers a more direct connection to the history of Kenilworth Castle between 1100 and 1300. Source D’s architectural focus provides valuable insights into how the castle's structure reflected the needs of the time, while Source E may present the socio-political context but could lack details specifically related to the castle's physical attributes.
Step 4
Conclusion
Answer
Ultimately, the usefulness of each source depends on the specific focus of the historian's study. If the researcher is primarily interested in architectural developments, then Source D would be more useful. Conversely, if the interest lies in the political and social narratives of the period, Source E may hold greater value. A comprehensive understanding would ideally incorporate insights from both sources.