'Romeo remains an immature and unrealistic character throughout the play.' To what extent do you agree with this view of Shakespeare’s portrayal of Romeo? Explore at least two moments from the play to support your ideas. - OCR - GCSE English Literature - Question 2 - 2021 - Paper 1

Shakespeare’s portrayal of Romeo in 'Romeo and Juliet' can be seen as both immature and fantastical, yet these traits also serve to highlight his humanity and the intensity of young love.

Moment 1: The First Encounter with Juliet

One key moment that emphasizes Romeo's immaturity is his initial infatuation with Juliet during the Capulet party. At first, he is consumed by his passion for Rosaline, but upon seeing Juliet, his affections switch almost instantaneously. This rapid shift illustrates a lack of depth in his emotional understanding, revealing a character who loves more for the thrill of being in love than for genuine connection. His impulsive decision to pursue Juliet, despite the family feud, further showcases his reckless romantic idealism.

Moment 2: The Death of Mercutio

In Act 3, the death of Mercutio acts as a pivotal point that reveals Romeo's emotional volatility and immaturity. Rather than attempting to diffuse the escalating conflict with Tybalt, Romeo’s need for vengeance leads him to kill Tybalt, a decision that drastically alters the course of events. This reaction reflects his inability to cope with loss and illustrates an unrealistic view of love that does not account for the consequences of violence. Again, Romeo's actions stem from youthful passion rather than reasoned thought, reinforcing the notion of his immaturity.

Conclusion

Ultimately, while it is easy to label Romeo as an immature character, it is essential to consider that this portrayal encapsulates the fervor of youthful emotions, love, and the impulsive nature of adolescence. His journey may appear unrealistic, but it serves a greater purpose in illustrating both the beauty and tragedy of young love.