Compare the views of Sources A and B about the relationship between John Balliol and Edward I - Scottish Highers History - Question 1 - 2018

Both sources highlight the tension between John Balliol and Edward I. Source A focuses on Edward's manipulation of Balliol, emphasizing how Balliol was summoned to Westminster to answer for his actions, illustrating Edward's dominance. In contrast, Source B discusses events leading to Balliol's initial kingship, suggesting that while they interacted as leaders, Edward's demands directly undermined Balliol's authority.

Furthermore, Source A illustrates a scenario where Balliol was pressured to submit to Edward's authority, whereas Source B portrays the background and establishment of Balliol's reign, indicating that he was not entirely without agency initially.

Overall, both sources agree on the power dynamics between the two figures, with Source A indicating a more direct subjugation by Edward, while Source B provides context for Balliol's initial acceptance of Scottish kingship.