Photo AI
Study Sources A, B and C then attempt the question which follows - Scottish Highers Modern Studies - Question 3 - 2022
Question 3
Study Sources A, B and C then attempt the question which follows. Source A THE IMPACT OF ALCOHOL IN SCOTLAND 17% of alcohol is bought in supermarkets. £3.6 billi... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Study Sources A, B and C then attempt the question which follows - Scottish Highers Modern Studies - Question 3 - 2022
Step 1
Evaluate the reliability of Source A
Answer
Source A provides valuable statistical information regarding alcohol consumption in Scotland. However, while it presents figures such as '£3.6 billion' and '16,000 more alcohol outlets than schools', one must consider the source of the data. The statistics could be outdated or influenced by specific agendas. Therefore, assessing the reliability involves checking if the data is corroborated by other reputable sources.
Step 2
Evaluate the reliability of Source B
Answer
Source B, created by YouGov, indicates voting trends among different age demographics from the 2019 general election. This data appears reliable as YouGov is a recognized polling organization known for its systematic methodology. The clear presentation of percentages supports its credibility; however, biases in political polling or external social factors must be considered as potential reliability issues.
Step 3
Evaluate the reliability of Source C
Answer
Source C provides insights into gender wage disparity, showing both men’s and women’s median hourly pay alongside a gap chart. This data, sourced from the Office for National Statistics, is usually well-regarded due to the thorough research it tends to undergo. Nonetheless, the gap visualization may need additional context to interpret fully, which could affect its reliability.
Step 4
Conclusion on the most reliable source
Answer
In conclusion, while all three sources provide relevant information, Source B stands out as the most reliable due to its backing by a respected polling company and clear presentation. Source C follows closely, given its origins from a legitimate statistical office, but may lack some context. Source A, while informative, raises questions about the validity and potential biases in its interpretation.