Photo AI
Study Sources A, B and C then attempt the question that follows - Scottish Highers Modern Studies - Question 3 - 2019
Question 3
Study Sources A, B and C then attempt the question that follows. Source A Only a third of Scots support independence Q: The second question will ask whether you a... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Study Sources A, B and C then attempt the question that follows - Scottish Highers Modern Studies - Question 3 - 2019
Step 1
Evaluate Source A
Answer
Source A can be considered relatively reliable as it presents data from a reputable polling source, Ipsos Mori. The survey indicates that only a third of Scots support independence, highlighting a clear indication of public opinion. However, since the data is from 2011, there may have been changes in sentiment since then, leading to a potential undermining of its current relevance.
Step 2
Evaluate Source B
Answer
Source B, which promotes the idea of leaving the EU by claiming substantial weekly savings (£350 million) to be redirected to the NHS, stems from Vote Leave, a political campaign. While this information may seem persuasive, it can be categorized as biased since it serves the agenda of a political party. Consequently, its reliability is questionable, as it may omit critical data about the economic implications of EU membership.
Step 3
Evaluate Source C
Answer
Source C presents electoral results indicating that the Tories have a low voting percentage (11%) in Bethnal Green and Bow. As a leaflet from the Green Party, it is intended to advance their political position, which raises concerns about its reliability. Political leaflets often depict selective or misleading data to influence voter perception. Therefore, while the figures might be accurate, the context and intent behind the information must be scrutinized.
Step 4
Overall Conclusion
Answer
In comparison, Source A is the most reliable due to its basis in polling data from an established organization, despite its age. Sources B and C, while they offer factual data, are less reliable due to their political motivations and potential bias. Thus, Source A provides a more objective assessment of public opinion concerning Scottish independence.