18.4.2 Legislative Process: Differences Between Chambers

---

House of Representatives

First Reading and Committee Stage

In the House, bills are introduced and quickly assigned to a relevant standing committee. The committee plays a crucial role in determining whether the bill will proceed. If the committee decides not to consider the bill, it may be "pigeonholed," effectively killing it.

Timetabling and Rules

The House Rules Committee controls the flow of legislation to the floor. This committee decides whether a bill will be debated on the House floor, how long the debate will last, and whether amendments can be added. The rules set by this committee are critical in determining the bill's chances of success.

Second Reading and Debate

During the second reading, the bill is debated on the floor of the House. Amendments may be proposed and added to the bill during this stage, subject to the rules established by the House Rules Committee.

Third Reading and Final Vote

After the debate and amendments, the bill proceeds to a third reading, where it is subjected to a final vote. If the bill passes, it moves to the Senate for consideration.

---

Senate

First Reading and Committee Stage

Similar to the House, the Senate begins by assigning bills to relevant committees. These committees hold hearings, amend the bill as necessary, and decide whether to send it to the floor for debate.

Timetabling and Unanimous Consent

In the Senate, the process of scheduling bills for debate is more flexible and relies on unanimous consent agreements between Senate leaders. This means that all senators must agree to bring a bill to the floor. Without unanimous consent, a bill may never be debated.

Second Reading and Debate

The Senate allows for unlimited debate on bills, which can lead to the use of the filibuster. A filibuster is a tactic where one or more senators extend debate on a bill to delay or block its passage. To end a filibuster, the Senate must invoke cloture, which requires the approval of 60 senators. Once cloture is invoked, the debate is limited, and the bill can proceed to a vote.

Third Reading and Final Vote

After the debate, the bill goes through a third reading and is then put to a final vote. If the bill passes, it moves to the House (if it originated in the Senate) or goes to the President for approval.

---

Key Differences in the Legislative Process

• Filibuster:

---

Comparison Table

Aspect	House of Representatives	Senate
Committee Stage	Bills assigned to committees; may be pigeonholed or proceed after hearings	Similar process; committees hold hearings and decide on progression
Timetabling	Controlled by the House Rules Committee, which sets debate rules	Determined by unanimous consent agreements among Senate leaders
Debate	Strictly timed and controlled by the Rules Committee	Unlimited debate; filibuster possible
Filibuster	Not applicable; no equivalent mechanism	Can delay/block legislation unless cloture is invoked (60 votes)
Amendments	Amendments are controlled and limited by the Rules Committee	More freely proposed; amendments can significantly alter bills
Final Vote	Occurs after third reading; bill moves to Senate or President if passed	Similar process; moves to House or President if passed

---

Conclusion

The legislative process in the House of Representatives and the Senate reflects the different priorities and structures of the two chambers. The House, with its larger membership and shorter terms, operates under stricter rules to manage debate and amendments efficiently. The Senate, with its smaller size and longer terms, allows for more extensive debate and individual influence, exemplified by the filibuster. Understanding these differences is crucial to grasping how legislation is crafted and passed in the U.S. Congress.