Consent in Organ Donation

Religious, Moral and Philosophical Studies

Organ Donation - Informed & Presumed

Organ Donation

Organ donation is a vital aspect of healthcare, where individuals voluntarily donate their organs (such as the heart, lungs, liver, kidneys, etc.) for transplantation into others who are in need of these organs. The act of organ donation plays a critical role in saving lives and improving the quality of life for recipients.

Consent in Organ Donation

Consent is a fundamental ethical and legal consideration in organ donation. It involves the individual's willingness and authorization to donate their organs after death.

Informed Consent

Informed consent is a crucial aspect of organ donation. It requires individuals to be fully aware of the details and implications of their decision to donate.

• In Scotland, the Human Tissue (Scotland) Act 2006 outlines the legal requirements for informed consent in organ donation. Under this act, an individual must provide clear and unambiguous consent for organ donation during their lifetime.
• The individual must have the capacity to understand the nature and consequences of their decision. They should be informed about the donation process, potential risks, and alternative options.
• Informed consent ensures that the donor's autonomy and choice are respected, promoting ethical and moral values in organ transplantation.

Presumed Consent

• Presumed consent, also known as "opt-out" or "deemed consent," is a different approach to organ donation, where the default assumption is that individuals are willing to donate their organs unless they explicitly refuse.
• Scotland passed the Human Tissue (Authorization) (Scotland) Act 2019, which introduced presumed consent for organ and tissue donation. This act allows organs to be donated unless the deceased individual has registered an objection or their family provides evidence of the deceased's objection.

---

Consent in Organ Donation

Religious, Moral and Philosophical Studies

• Family involvement is still an important consideration in cases of presumed consent, as the family's wishes may be respected.
• The introduction of presumed consent aims to increase organ donation rates by making the default position one of donation, though it remains a sensitive and ethical issue due to concerns about the validity of presumed consent in reflecting individuals' true wishes.

Conclusion

Consent is a pivotal ethical and legal aspect of organ donation in Scotland. Informed consent ensures that individuals make conscious decisions about their organ donation, while presumed consent changes the default position to donation, unless objections are registered or provided by the family. These approaches reflect the complex ethical and moral considerations involved in organ transplantation, emphasizing respect for individual autonomy and societal health needs.