Photo AI
Use this extract to answer Question 1 - Edexcel - GCSE English Literature - Question 1 - 2021 - Paper 1
Question 1
Use this extract to answer Question 1. Jane Eyre: Charlotte Brontë In Chapter 29, Jane Eyre has been nursed back to health by Diana and Mary Rivers and Jane is exp... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Use this extract to answer Question 1 - Edexcel - GCSE English Literature - Question 1 - 2021 - Paper 1
Step 1
How is St John Rivers presented in this extract?
Answer
St John Rivers is depicted as a demanding and somewhat thoughtless character. His interactions with Diana indicate a level of impatience when he wants Jane to communicate more, as he is concerned about her well-being, yet shows little sensitivity to her state. The use of contractions in Diana's dialogue, 'Don't make her talk any more now, St John,' portrays a firm yet caring attitude. This contrast highlights St John's more direct approach, showcasing a collision between his rational demands and Diana's emotional concern.
Additionally, the way St John questions Jane about her identity, 'You said your name was Jane Elliott?' reflects both his authority and possible insensitivity, as he presses her without apparent consideration for her feelings.
Step 2
What does the dialogue reveal about Diana's perspective?
Answer
Diana appears sympathetic towards Jane, evident in her protective tone. Her insistence that Jane should not talk further suggests she understands Jane’s fragile state. This underscores her nurturing role, contrasting with St John's more analytical demeanor. Diana’s choice of words reflects her intelligence and sensitivity, allowing readers to see her as a character who balances concern for Jane's health with the need to assert control in a male-dominated environment.
Step 3
Explain Jane's reaction when she hears the alias 'Miss Elliott'.
Answer
Jane's involuntary reaction, noted by Mr. Rivers, indicates a clash between her past identity and present situation. The mention of her alias surprises her, which suggests an emotional conflict tied to her sense of self. By distancing herself from the name Jane Elliott, she expresses her struggle with her new identity, revealing the transformative journey she has undergone. Her discomfort illustrates the theme of identity in 'Jane Eyre', reflecting broader issues of self-acceptance and societal roles.