Photo AI
Study Sources A to C - OCR Gateway - GCSE History - Question 2 - 2021 - Paper 1
Question 2
Study Sources A to C. ‘Henry VIII reformed the English church between 1530 and 1534 for religious reasons.’ How far do Sources A to C convince you that this st... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Study Sources A to C - OCR Gateway - GCSE History - Question 2 - 2021 - Paper 1
Step 1
Evaluate Source A
Answer
Source A suggests that Henry VIII's actions were driven by his desire for a male heir rather than purely for religious reasons. It highlights concerns over his marriage to Catherine and his need to have a legitimate son. Therefore, while his reforms impacted the church, the motives were complex and not solely religious.
Step 2
Evaluate Source B
Answer
Source B contributes to the understanding that Henry VIII's break from Rome was influenced by political motives, particularly his desire to secure power and control over the church. It presents the perspective that the Act of Supremacy was not just a religious transformation but a strategic political maneuver.
Step 3
Evaluate Source C
Answer
Source C presents evidence that supports the argument that religious motivations were involved, particularly in the establishment of the Church of England. However, its overall significance lies in the interconnectedness of political, personal, and religious reasons for the reformation, suggesting that the statement is not fully aligned with just religious motives.
Step 4
Overall Conclusion
Answer
In conclusion, while Sources A, B, and C each present elements that contribute to understanding Henry VIII's reformation of the church, they collectively suggest that his motives were multifaceted. The interplay between religious needs and personal ambitions, particularly in securing a male heir and gaining greater power, indicate that the statement oversimplifies the complex motivations behind the reforms.