Photo AI
QUESTION 5: NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH BY JOHN KANI Study SOURCE F below and answer the questions that follow - NSC Dramatic Arts - Question 5 - 2019 - Paper 1
Question 5
QUESTION 5: NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH BY JOHN KANI Study SOURCE F below and answer the questions that follow. SOURCE F AN EXTRACT FROM NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH THANDO: ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:QUESTION 5: NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH BY JOHN KANI Study SOURCE F below and answer the questions that follow - NSC Dramatic Arts - Question 5 - 2019 - Paper 1
Step 1
5.1 Why are Mandisa and Thando arguing?
Answer
Mandisa and Thando are arguing because they have different perspectives on the concept of revenge versus reconciliation in the context of South Africa's transition from apartheid. Mandisa emphasizes the need for accountability and questions the morality of selling out for international approval, reflecting her concern for the people who might seek revenge. On the other hand, Thando advocates for peace and stability, believing that focusing on rebuilding the nation is more critical than seeking revenge.
Step 2
5.2 Analyse why the dialogue in SOURCE F may be described as realistic.
Answer
The dialogue in SOURCE F can be described as realistic because it captures genuine emotions and reactions of individuals discussing their past experiences related to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC). The characters express conflicting views, showcasing the tension and complexity around the themes of forgiveness and accountability. Their conversational flow, interruptions, and frustrations mirror real-life discussions about sensitive historical events, making it relatable and credible.
Step 3
5.3 Describe a suitable set for the scene.
Answer
A suitable set for the scene could depict a modest living room that reflects the struggles and aspirations of the characters. It might include:
- A comfortable couch to symbolize home and safety.
- A coffee table with a framed photo of Themba, representing loss and memory.
- Bookshelves filled with literature to reflect Thando's profession as a librarian and the importance of education.
- Subtle decor items that convey a sense of cultural heritage and personal history, emphasizing the emotional weight of the dialogue.
Step 4
5.4 Explain the choices the actors might make to block this scene in terms of the placement and movement of characters.
Answer
In blocking this scene, the actors might choose to:
- Position Mandisa and Thando at opposite ends of the stage to visually represent their opposing viewpoints, creating a physical sense of distance.
- Use gestural movements to enhance emotional expressions, such as Thando pacing while expressing frustration and Mandisa remaining stationary to signify her grounded stance.
- Bring the characters closer during moments of heightened emotion to indicate connection despite their disagreement, emphasizing the complexity of their relationship.
Step 5
5.5 The actor playing Mandisa could reflect an understanding of Stanislavski's system. How?
Answer
The actor portraying Mandisa could reflect an understanding of Stanislavski's system by:
- Using physical actions and facial expressions to convey Mandisa's emotional state, thus creating a believable character. For example, she might exhibit tension in her posture when discussing the injustices of the past.
- Engaging with her internal monologue, allowing her to express feelings of anger and hurt authentically, which will reflect on stage.
- Establishing a strong connection with the audience by actively listening and responding to Thando’s dialogue, making their interaction appear dynamic and real.
Step 6
5.6 The role of women in society is portrayed in different ways in the play.
Answer
In the play, the role of women is portrayed through various lenses:
- Mandisa is depicted as a strong, independent woman who is unafraid to voice her opinions, contrasting traditional gender roles.
- She also represents women’s struggles for acknowledgment and justice in a patriarchal society, as she challenges Thando's views.
- Other female characters, while sometimes subservient to male authority (like Thelma), also exhibit resilience and determination to address their societal positions. This duality illustrates the broader struggles women face in post-apartheid South Africa, showcasing both empowerment and challenges.