Photo AI
VRAAG 5: NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH DEUR JOHN KANI THANDO: Mandisa, we had a choice - NSC Dramatic Arts - Question 5 - 2019 - Paper 1
Question 5
VRAAG 5: NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH DEUR JOHN KANI THANDO: Mandisa, we had a choice. We could have gone for revenge. We could have gone for Nuremberg-style trials but ho... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:VRAAG 5: NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH DEUR JOHN KANI THANDO: Mandisa, we had a choice - NSC Dramatic Arts - Question 5 - 2019 - Paper 1
Step 1
5.1 Waarom stry Mandisa en Thando?
Answer
Mandisa and Thando argue because they hold different viewpoints on the issues, situations, and outcomes based on the framework of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC). Mandisa believes that they are passive victims of the circumstances, while Thando emphasizes the importance of rebuilding the nation and moving forward without vengeance.
Step 2
5.2 Analyserer waarom die dialoog in BRON F as realiteitsbeskryf kan word.
Answer
The dialogue in BRON F is realistic as it portrays genuine struggles and conflicting emotions between characters. It addresses the aftermath of apartheid and the choices the leaders faced about forgiveness versus revenge, highlighting the human experience of grief, hope, and the longing for reconciliation amidst a fraught historical context.
Step 3
5.3 Beskryf 'n geskikte dekselsnel vir hierdie toneel.
Answer
In this scene, the setting could reflect a modest room in the Makhaya household, with simple furniture illustrating their economic struggles. The presence of personal items like books and family photographs can emphasize the dichotomy of their past lives against the backdrop of their current debate on forgiveness and justice.
Step 4
5.4 Beskryf die keuses wat jy sou maak om hierdie toneel te blokkeer en op te voer.
Answer
To block and stage this scene effectively, I would emphasize emotional delivery, with actors using physical expressions and movement to convey the tension between Mandisa and Thando. The use of silence and pauses would be critical, as they could express the weight of unspoken truths and unacknowledged pain.
Step 5
5.5 Stel voor hoe die aksie wat Mandisa speel Stanislavski se stelsel in werking kan gebruik om hierdie karakter te wees.
Answer
Mandisa could implement Stanislavski's system by deeply exploring her character's emotional background, motivations, and objectives. She should embody the physicality of her experiences and utilize sense memory to evoke genuine feelings, ensuring that her portrayal remains relatable and authentic.
Step 6
5.6 Verwys na die aantekening hieronder en BYLAE B om jou naaswerk te lei.
Answer
This section should accentuate Mandisa's conflicts with societal expectancies and the pressures she faces in navigating personal versus collective healing. Her interaction with Thando can illustrate the broader societal dilemmas regarding justice and reconciliation, shedding light on their shared journey towards understanding.
Step 7
5.7 Thando se teorie is relevant wanneer dit handel oor die sosio-politieke tekstuur.
Answer
Thando's approach speaks to the socio-political landscape, advocating for unity and restoration over vindictiveness. His belief underscores the need to transcend past grievances for national healing, reflecting a pivotal moment in South African history where decisions on forgiveness versus revenge shaped collective futures.