Photo AI
Sukey and Burgert have different opinions on Marta's situation - NSC English FAL - Question 6 - 2016 - Paper 2
Question 6
Sukey and Burgert have different opinions on Marta's situation. 'Pa, pray if you like, but I shall not pray with you. There is no God or surely He would have saved ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Sukey and Burgert have different opinions on Marta's situation - NSC English FAL - Question 6 - 2016 - Paper 2
Step 1
6.1.3 Show how Marta and Jan are different in character by referring to relevant examples from the short story.
Answer
Marta is characterized as sensitive and loyal to her father. She shows a willingness to sacrifice for her family's financial stability. In contrast, Jan is portrayed as boastful and insensitive. He lacks empathy, particularly when he drives Marta into marrying old Jan Redlinghuis, focusing more on his own interests than on Marta's feelings.
Step 2
6.1.4 Refer to lines 6–7 ('Is it not ... to my furrow?').
Answer
In lines 6–7, the phrase reflects an attitude of entitlement and a sense of superiority by Jan. He believes that their actions were justified as they were necessary for the family’s land but lacks consideration for Marta's dignity and feelings in the matter.
Step 3
Step 4
6.1.6 Using your OWN words, explain why the following statement is FALSE: State TWO points.
Answer
The statement is false because, firstly, Marta's actions demonstrate her loyalty to her family rather than being merely obedient to Jan. Secondly, it overlooks the emotional turmoil she experiences due to her forced marriage, which is not just an act of submission but a significant sacrifice.
Step 5
6.1.6 Identify and discuss ONE theme of the short story which is evident in lines 11–13 ('Yes, I said ... before all Platkops').
Answer
One evident theme in this part of the story is the 'sacrifice for family.' This theme highlights how familial duty can lead to personal suffering, as demonstrated by Marta being sold to Jan Redlinghuis, which causes shame and humiliation, not just for her but for her entire family.
Step 6
6.1.7 Do you sympathize with Marta when she is paraded in public? Discuss your view.
Answer
Yes, I sympathize with Marta when she is paraded in public. She is a victim of circumstance and familial obligations, stripped of her agency. This public humiliation highlights not just her suffering but reflects the deeper societal issues of gender and the expectations placed on women during that time.