Photo AI
The animals on Animal Farm are victims of circumstance rather than of their own flaws - NSC English HL - Question 6 - 2016 - Paper 2
Question 6
The animals on Animal Farm are victims of circumstance rather than of their own flaws. Critically discuss the extent to which you agree with the above statement. Y... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:The animals on Animal Farm are victims of circumstance rather than of their own flaws - NSC English HL - Question 6 - 2016 - Paper 2
Step 1
Circumstances on Manor Farm
Answer
The circumstances on Manor Farm are dire and ultimately lead to the animals' rebellion. Under the oppressive rule of Mr. Jones, the animals experience severe hardship and exploitation. This situation provokes a strong desire for change, making it clear that the external environment is a major factor in their initial revolt.
Step 2
Inherent Flaws of the Animals
Answer
Despite being victims of their circumstances, the animals also possess intrinsic weaknesses. Their naivety, illustrated by Snowball's trust in Napoleon, demonstrates a lack of critical thinking that allows their subjugation to continue after the rebellion. Snowball's idealism blinds him to the reality of power struggles, meaning that their flaws significantly contribute to their downfall.
Step 3
Manipulation by Leaders
Answer
Post-rebellion, the animals are subjected to manipulation by their leaders, particularly Napoleon. The pigs exploit the other animals' struggles for a better life. The animals’ inability to recognize their leaders’ growing power reflects not just circumstance but their own flaws in judgment, making them complicit in their continued oppression.
Step 4
Outcome of the Revolution
Answer
In conclusion, while the animals are initially victims of their oppressive circumstances, their own inherent flaws and the manipulation by their leaders lead to their persistent state of victimization. This duality illustrates the complexities of their situation, suggesting that both external circumstances and internal weaknesses contribute to their fate.