Photo AI
What is suggested by the phrase, 'down there' (line 3) in the context of the poem? 4.2 Account for the use of brackets throughout the poem - NSC English HL - Question 4 - 2019 - Paper 2
Question 4
What is suggested by the phrase, 'down there' (line 3) in the context of the poem? 4.2 Account for the use of brackets throughout the poem. 4.3 Refer to line 24: '... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:What is suggested by the phrase, 'down there' (line 3) in the context of the poem? 4.2 Account for the use of brackets throughout the poem - NSC English HL - Question 4 - 2019 - Paper 2
Step 1
What is suggested by the phrase, 'down there' (line 3) in the context of the poem?
Answer
The phrase 'down there' suggests a physical and emotional distance between the prisoners. It implies a sense of isolation and confinement. The connotation of 'down' indicates a lower status, as if the prisoners are trapped in a hierarchical system devoid of human connection.
Step 2
Account for the use of brackets throughout the poem.
Answer
The brackets in the poem serve to enclose the translation or interpretation of sign language utilized by the prisoners. This choice allows the reader to comprehend the nuances of communication occurring between the characters, fostering a greater understanding of their plight. Furthermore, the use of brackets draws attention to the importance of these translations, highlighting the reader's involvement in the conversation.
Step 3
Refer to line 24: 'His free hand, the talkative one'. Discuss the irony in this line.
Answer
In this line, the irony lies in the contrast between the idea of a 'free hand' and the speaker's actual lack of freedom. Although the hand may be physically free, the man remains a prisoner, unable to truly express himself or communicate meaningfully with others. The adjective 'talkative' further emphasizes the potential for expression that is stifled by his circumstances.
Step 4
Refer to the title. Is the title appropriate in the context of the poem? Justify your response.
Answer
Yes, the title aptly reflects the theme of ubuntu, which signifies a sense of community and interconnectedness among humanity. It suggests that despite the struggles faced by the prisoners, there is an underlying bond of compassion and support that connects them. The title resonates with the poem’s exploration of how these relationships are vital for maintaining one’s humanity amidst dehumanizing conditions.