Photo AI
RUGBY LEAGUE GAME – James Kirkup Sport is absurd, and sad - NSC English HL - Question 2 - 2017 - Paper 2
Question 2
RUGBY LEAGUE GAME – James Kirkup Sport is absurd, and sad. Those grown men. Just look, In those dreary long blue shorts, Those ringed stockings, Edwardian, Balding p... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:RUGBY LEAGUE GAME – James Kirkup Sport is absurd, and sad - NSC English HL - Question 2 - 2017 - Paper 2
Step 1
2.1 What impression does the speaker convey in his reference to 'Those grown men' (line 2)?
Answer
The speaker conveys a sense of irony regarding adult men participating in a boys' game. He highlights the absurdity of grown men engaging in an activity that is traditionally associated with youthful exuberance. This suggests that these men are clinging to their unfulfilled dreams of youth, indicating their disconnect from the realities of adulthood.
Step 2
2.2 Comment on the use of the word, 'gallantly' (line 7).
Answer
The term 'gallantly' is used somewhat sarcastically in this context. While it traditionally connotes bravery and chivalry, here it contrasts with the reality of the men’s actions—violent tackles in the mud. It underlines the absurdity of their attempts to appear noble as they engage in activities that are anything but dignified.
Step 3
2.3 Refer to lines 15–16: 'Groping their blind way back/To noble youth'.
Answer
The imagery of 'groping their blind way back' suggests that the men lack clarity and direction in their attempts to reclaim their youth. They are described as 'blind', indicating an inability to truly understand how to achieve their nostalgic aspirations, resulting in awkward attempts that seem futile and misguided.
Step 4
2.4 Critically discuss how the contrast in the last stanza reflects the satirical nature of the poem.
Answer
In the final stanza, the contrast between the untamed boys of the past and the domesticated men of the present emphasizes the theme of lost vitality. The speaker critiques their futile efforts to recapture their youth, using phrases like 'vainly' to highlight the absurdity of their attempts. This duality serves to satirize the unrealistic expectations men have about returning to their youthful vigor, reinforcing the poem’s overall ironic tone.