Photo AI
Considering the above statement, write a paragraph in which you discuss how the artists in FIGURE 3a and FIGURE 3b portrayed their protest against the injustices of mankind - NSC Visual Arts - Question 3 - 2020 - Paper 1
Question 3
Considering the above statement, write a paragraph in which you discuss how the artists in FIGURE 3a and FIGURE 3b portrayed their protest against the injustices of ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Considering the above statement, write a paragraph in which you discuss how the artists in FIGURE 3a and FIGURE 3b portrayed their protest against the injustices of mankind - NSC Visual Arts - Question 3 - 2020 - Paper 1
Step 1
Imagery and symbolism
Answer
In FIGURE 3a, Picasso employs fragmented elements representing the chaos of war. The sun symbolizes hope amidst destruction, while the horse embodies suffering and struggle. The imagery of a hand holding a broken sword signifies an appeal for peace after conflict. Conversely, FIGURE 3b by Mabula delves into the aftermath of a mining tragedy, featuring a woman who embodies the financial struggles of widows. The background mine illustration captures the source of despair, while the supermarket subtly contrasts with the stark reality of survival.
Step 2
Similarities and differences
Answer
Both artworks share a common theme of loss and struggle against oppressive forces. However, they differ in their mediums; Picasso uses traditional painting techniques, while Mabula incorporates elements of photography in FIGURE 3b, enhancing the realism of the scene. This difference shapes how viewers connect with each narrative, as Mabula's portrayal may evoke a more immediate emotional response due to its photographic realism.
Step 3
Style
Answer
Picasso's style in FIGURE 3a reflects Cubist influences, employing fragmented forms and bold lines that convey movement and emotion. In contrast, Mabula's FIGURE 3b features elements of surrealism, where the incorporation of real-life imagery intermingles with artistic interpretation, providing a stark commentary on the realities faced by the widows.
Step 4
Meaning and messages
Answer
The overarching message in FIGURE 3a critiques the tragedy of war and its impact on innocent lives, with Picasso conveying the poignancy of loss. Mabula's work highlights social injustices, showcasing the plight of women left to fend for themselves in the wake of violence against their husbands. Both pieces serve as powerful reminders of the consequences of historical events on ordinary lives.
Step 5
Which artwork evokes the strongest emotion. Motivate your answer.
Answer
While both artworks are emotionally charged, FIGURE 3b evokes a stronger emotional response due to its direct portrayal of contemporary struggle. The realism inherent in Mabula's use of photography, juxtaposed with the plight of widows and the symbolism of struggle, creates a compelling narrative that resonates profoundly with viewers, urging them to confront social injustices directly.