With reference to the visual sources shown in FIGURES 1a and 1b, write a comparative analysis of the two works (1 page) in which you discuss the following: - Subject matter - Composition and focal point - The use of colour - Style - The atmosphere and mood - The use of the figure(s) in each work Which artwork do you think has the greatest visual impact? Substantiate your answer. - NSC Visual Arts - Question 1 - 2017 - Paper 1

In Figure 1a, the women are centralized, creating a vivid focal point. The use of perspective guides the viewer's eye while the positioning of the cyclist and the house establishes depth. In contrast, Figure 1b uses a linear perspective to narrate the story of moving, allowing the viewer to engage with the challenges depicted.

Figure 1a employs vibrant, contrasting colours to evoke emotion and draw attention to the subjects, while Figure 1b uses more subdued tones, reflecting the somber theme of relocation and survival under difficult conditions.

The expressionistic style in Figure 1a suggests energy and movement, with bold brushwork. Figure 1b adopts a more realistic approach, simplifying shapes and employing angularity to depict the struggle of the figures, thereby enhancing the narrative.

Figure 1a conveys a sense of energy and liveliness, while Figure 1b evokes sadness and a sense of disorientation, allowing the viewer to sympathize with the experiences of those depicted.

In Figure 1a, figures are central to showcasing everyday life, while in Figure 1b, they symbolize displacement and the emotional weight of forced relocation. Each serves to enhance the narrative conveyed by the respective artwork.

Figure 1a is suggested to have the greatest visual impact due to its dynamic use of colour and composition, engaging the viewer and enhancing the emotional connection to the subjects' lives.