Photo AI
Considering the above statement, write a paragraph in which you discuss how the artists in FIGURE 3a and FIGURE 3b portrayed their protest against the injustices of mankind - NSC Visual Arts - Question 3 - 2020 - Paper 1
Question 3
Considering the above statement, write a paragraph in which you discuss how the artists in FIGURE 3a and FIGURE 3b portrayed their protest against the injustices of ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Considering the above statement, write a paragraph in which you discuss how the artists in FIGURE 3a and FIGURE 3b portrayed their protest against the injustices of mankind - NSC Visual Arts - Question 3 - 2020 - Paper 1
Step 1
Imagery and symbolism
Answer
In FIGURE 3a, Pablo Picasso uses fragmented representations of people and animals, which conveys the intense emotional struggle faced during wartime. The imagery includes a sun, symbolizing hope, juxtaposed with a broken sword, representing the violence and turmoil of the Spanish Civil War. The horse, central to the composition, symbolizes both power and suffering, reminding viewers of the casualties of war. In FIGURE 3b, Ayanda Mabula employs a busy scene of urban life, including OK Bazars, which suggests everyday normality against a backdrop of tragedy. The woman in the center holds a chicken, a representation of survival and resilience, echoing the struggles of widows after the Marikana incident. The imagery in both artworks poignantly reflects the injustices faced by these communities.
Step 2
Similarities and differences
Answer
Both artists address human suffering through their work; however, their approaches vary significantly. Similarities include their use of powerful symbolism to invoke empathy from the viewer. Differences lie in the medium and style; Picasso's work in FIGURE 3a employs Cubist influences, with fragmented shapes and bold lines creating a jagged representation of reality. In contrast, Mabula’s work in FIGURE 3b incorporates surrealist elements coupled with photographic details, offering a stark and immediate connection to contemporary issues.
Step 3
Style
Answer
Picasso’s style in FIGURE 3a is rooted in Cubism, which allows him to express multi-faceted perspectives within a single frame, enhancing the emotional impact of his message. Mabula, on the other hand, uses a more realistic style in FIGURE 3b, featuring layered imagery that connects the viewers to the social and political struggles faced by the subjects. This stylistic choice enables Mabula to include a narrative that resonates with present-day audiences.
Step 4
Meaning and messages
Answer
In FIGURE 3a, the overarching message reflects the harrowing impacts of war on innocent lives, particularly women and children. Picasso encapsulates the chaos and devastation of conflict through distorted figures and imagery. In FIGURE 3b, Mabula conveys a narrative of survival and resilience amidst systemic violence and social inequities. The juxtaposition of everyday life against a backdrop of tragedy highlights the ongoing struggles for justice and recognition.
Step 5
Which artwork evokes the strongest emotion? Motivate your answer.
Answer
While both artworks elicit profound emotional responses, FIGURE 3a evokes a more intense reaction through its dramatic imagery and chaotic composition. The fragmented figures and stark symbolism of loss and suffering engage viewers on a visceral level, prompting deep reflection on the consequences of war. Picasso's work serves as a haunting reminder of the past, making it emotionally gripping in its portrayal of tragedy.