With reference to the visual sources shown in FIGURES 1a and 1b, write a comparative analysis of the two works (1 page) in which you discuss the following: - Subject matter - Composition and focal point - The use of colour - Style - The atmosphere and mood - The use of the figure(s) in each work Which artwork do you think has the greatest visual impact? Substantiate your answer. - NSC Visual Arts - Question 1 - 2017 - Paper 1

In FIGURE 1a, the composition employs a linear perspective, with the larger figures profiling prominently in the foreground, allowing the background to recede. The structuring of elements like the women and the truck establishes a dynamic focal point. In FIGURE 1b, the composition presents a more chaotic scene, with the figures forming a triangular layout that emphasizes their dance of struggle against the backdrop of a stark environment.

The color palette in FIGURE 1a is vibrant, utilizing strong contrasting colors that create an elaborate visual experience. The warm tones reflect energy and vitality. Conversely, FIGURE 1b employs a more subdued and earthy color scheme that encapsulates sadness, with cooler tones lending an air of melancholy to the depicted struggle.

FIGURE 1a reflects a lively scene filled with expressionistic color and dynamic brushwork, akin to Maqhubela's style, which captures the energy of the township's life. In contrast, FIGURE 1b utilizes a simplified, more angular representation, with careful attention to the shapes and textures of the environment, resembling Clarke's technique.

In FIGURE 1a, there is an energetic and excited mood, reflecting the active lives of individuals bustling around. In contrast, FIGURE 1b conveys a sad and depressing atmosphere, portraying the sense of loss and struggle experienced by those returning to their homes after displacement.

FIGURE 1a uses figures to represent resilience and community spirit amid chaos. FIGURE 1b employs figures to portray dislocation and hardship, symbolizing the struggles caused by socio-political changes.

While both artworks are powerful, FIGURE 1a stands out due to its vibrant color scheme and dynamic portrayal of everyday life, which captures the viewer's attention more immediately compared to the softer tones and reflective nature of FIGURE 1b.