Nil Nil

Summary of the poem:

• "Nil Nil" by Don Paterson explores the theme of the ultimate insignificance of human efforts and existence. It presents two contrasting situations: the decline of a football club and the tragic death of a fighter pilot. Both stories illustrate how achievements and lives ultimately dwindle to nothing.

Inspiration for the poem:

• The poem is inspired by the idea that all human efforts and accomplishments eventually lose their significance and merge with the world itself. The title, "Nil Nil," which alludes to a football score of 0 - 0, highlights the theme of existence leading to nothing.

Form of the poem:

• The poem is structured in two stanzas. The first stanza is longer and describes the decline of the football club, while the second stanza is shorter and focuses on the pilot's tragic fate. This structural contrast reinforces the theme of decline and insignificance.

Summary of the Stanzas

Stanza 1:

In the first stanza of 'Nil Nil' by Don Paterson, the poem opens by describing a football club's moment of glory. The team's success is portrayed as a zenith, with a player named McGrandle depicted as godlike in his skills. The crowd's celebratory tossing of grey bonnets into the air symbolises their joy. However, the poem shifts to depict the gradual decline of the club, emphasising how key players depart, and their fortunes dwindle into financial ruin. The stanza also introduces a sense of irony, as even the club's momentary success is framed as a 'setback' in the context of their inevitable downfall.

---

Poetry

Stanza 2:

The second stanza of the poem shifts focus to a fighter pilot from the Leuchars base. This pilot returns from a mission, only to lose his way in the mist, paralleling the football team's descent. The perfect flying conditions take a tragic turn when his engine fails, causing the plane to crash. The pilot's misfortune is compounded when a prank removes his parachute. Socks rise into the air like doves, highlighting the absurdity of the situation. The stanza ends with a list of meaningless items left behind from the pilot's life, underscoring the idea of insignificance.

Epilogue:

Following the two narrative stanzas, an epilogue addresses the reader directly. The speaker reflects on the fading light and the path that disappears, symbolising the transient nature of existence. The speaker lists seemingly random concerns like road repairs, birdsong, weather, and nirvana, which further emphasise life's fleeting nature. The poem concludes with the idea that all stories thin down to a point of such refinement that even angels can't find meaning in them. This concluding section invites the reader to contemplate the theme of insignificance and the impermanence of life's narratives.

Themes

The Insignificance of Existence:

The poem explores the idea that all human achievements and lives eventually fade into obscurity. This theme is encapsulated in the title, "Nil Nil", suggesting that everything ends up signifying nothing. The decline of the football club and the pilot's tragic fate exemplify this theme.

• Quote: "Finally we are left with a solitary minor sentence: Goodbye."
• Development: This quote highlights the ultimate insignificance of the two stories and the people involved. The word "Goodbye" signifies the end of their narratives, emphasising the idea that all things eventually lead to nothing.

---

Poetry

Change:

The poem delves into the concept of change, depicting how moments of success can swiftly transition into periods of decline. The football team's journey from glory to failure and the pilot's transition from flying high to crashing exemplify the theme of change and transience.

• Quote: "the plot thinning down to a point so refined / not even the angels could dance on it."
• Development: This quote underscores the idea that life's plot gradually fades and becomes so insignificant that not even angels can find meaning in it. It reflects the inevitability of change and the fleeting nature of success and existence.

Imagery

The Crowd of Grey Bonnets:

In the first stanza, the crowd throws grey bonnets into the air to celebrate the football club's success. These bonnets falling out of the clouds symbolise the club's fading glory and the transience of achievement.

• Quote: "The crowd responds with a plague of grey bonnets."
• Development: The falling bonnets suggest that the club's success is temporary, and the grey colour represents the past, emphasising the club's decline and insignificance.

The Gallstone as a Ball:

In the second stanza, the pilot's gallstone becomes a ball that the small boy Horace kicks into the gutter. This image symbolises the reduction of a person's life and identity to something trivial and unremarkable.

• Quote: "his gallstone (his abandoned history) becomes a mere pebble kicked in a game."
• Development: The transformation of the gallstone into a pebble reflects the idea that even the most significant aspects of a person's life can be reduced to meaninglessness. It parallels the football club's descent into obscurity.

---

Poetry

Style techniques

Irony:

The poem employs irony, particularly in the description of the football team's success as a "setback" and the pilot's catch-up with the plane as a destructive event. This ironic tone highlights the contrast between initial optimism and the ultimate decline and insignificance.

• Quote: "He caught up with the plane / on the ground..."
• Development: This irony emphasises the unpredictability of life's outcomes and adds a layer of complexity to the narrative, underscoring the theme of change and insignificance.

Repetition and Parallelism:

The poem uses repetition and parallelism in the descriptions of the football club's decline and the pilot's descent, creating a structural and thematic connection between the two stories.

• Quote: "A football team loses its success... A fighter-pilot crashes his plane..."
• Development: The repetition and parallelism serve to reinforce the idea that both narratives follow a similar pattern of success to failure, contributing to the poem's overarching theme of the meaninglessness of existence.

Language Techniques

Simile:

The poem employs similes to create vivid comparisons, such as describing the pilot's descent "like an ash-key." These similes evoke powerful imagery and emphasise the fragility and insignificance of human endeavours.

• Quote: "sending him silently / twirling away like an ash-key..."
• Development: The simile enhances the reader's understanding of the pilot's lack of control over his fate and the vulnerability of human existence.

---

Poetry

Metaphor:

The use of metaphor is evident in the description of the crowd as a "plague of grey bonnets." This metaphorical language conveys the idea that the crowd's celebration is a fleeting and ultimately meaningless moment.

• Quote: "The crowd responds with a plague of grey bonnets."
• Development: The metaphor emphasises the transient nature of success and the contrast between the celebratory moment and the club's eventual decline.

In "Nil Nil," Don Paterson skillfully weaves together two seemingly unrelated stories to explore profound themes of insignificance, change, and the ephemeral nature of human existence. The poem's structure, language, and style techniques work in harmony to convey these themes and provoke contemplation about the meaning of life and our earthly efforts.

Personal Reflection

1. How does the poem 'Nil Nil' by Don Paterson challenge your perception of the significance of human achievements and existence?

2. What emotions does the poem evoke in you when considering the inevitable decline and transience of both the football club and the fighter pilot's story?

3. In what ways does 'Nil Nil' prompt you to reflect on the fleeting nature of life and the way we attach meaning to our experiences and endeavours?