Photo AI
Name a NOVEL or a SHORT STORY you have studied where a character changes in some way - Junior Cycle English - Question E - 2016
Question E
Name a NOVEL or a SHORT STORY you have studied where a character changes in some way. - Describe what the character is like before he or she changes. - Why do you ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Name a NOVEL or a SHORT STORY you have studied where a character changes in some way - Junior Cycle English - Question E - 2016
Step 1
Describe what the character is like before he or she changes.
Answer
In the novel 'The Catcher in the Rye' by J.D. Salinger, the protagonist Holden Caulfield is portrayed as a deeply troubled and cynical teenager. Before his change, Holden exhibits signs of isolation and alienation. He often criticizes the adult world, which he deems 'phony', and struggles to connect meaningfully with those around him. His behavior is erratic, marked by frequent emotional outbursts and a sense of pervasive sadness. Instances of his protective attitude towards his younger sister, Phoebe, reveal a softer side, yet he remains largely disengaged from his own emotions.
Step 2
Why do you think he or she changes?
Answer
Holden's change is primarily triggered by the traumatic experience of his younger brother, Allie’s, death. This loss profoundly affects his mental health, contributing to his withdrawal and grief. Throughout the story, he grapples with his emotions and the concept of growing up, which feels overwhelming. Additionally, his interactions with characters who care about him, such as Phoebe, culminate in a realization of the importance of connection and acceptance. This ongoing internal struggle drives his eventual shift from isolation to a desire for emotional honesty and connection.
Step 3
Do you prefer the character before or after he or she changes? Give reasons for your answer.
Answer
I prefer Holden after he changes, as he begins to display a semblance of understanding and acceptance of his emotions. This transformation signifies his growth and willingness to confront his pain rather than hide from it. After his change, Holden shows a more nuanced perspective on life and relationships. His newfound appreciation for the people in his life, particularly Phoebe, highlights his journey towards healing. This evolution from a state of despair to a glimmer of hope makes the character more relatable and empathetic, ultimately showcasing the complexities of adolescence.