Photo AI

Read this extract adapted from "4 Taste for Quiet and Other Disquieting Tales" by Judith Gorog, and answer the questions which follow - Junior Cycle English - Question 7 - 2007

Question icon

Question 7

Read-this-extract-adapted-from-"4-Taste-for-Quiet-and-Other-Disquieting-Tales"-by-Judith-Gorog,-and-answer-the-questions-which-follow-Junior Cycle English-Question 7-2007.png

Read this extract adapted from "4 Taste for Quiet and Other Disquieting Tales" by Judith Gorog, and answer the questions which follow. The surprising thing about Me... show full transcript

Worked Solution & Example Answer:Read this extract adapted from "4 Taste for Quiet and Other Disquieting Tales" by Judith Gorog, and answer the questions which follow - Junior Cycle English - Question 7 - 2007

Step 1

Like Melinda Alice as a friend? Explain why or why not, basing your answer on the short story above.

96%

114 rated

Answer

I would not like Melinda Alice as a friend. While she possesses some appealing qualities, such as ambition and creativity, her initial treatment of the snail indicates a lack of empathy. She seems self-involved, as her wishes are geared towards enhancing her own life rather than considering the feelings of others. A true friend should be compassionate and considerate, traits that Melinda Alice appears to struggle with.

Step 2

What you think the snail really thought of Melinda Alice.

99%

104 rated

Answer

The snail likely viewed Melinda Alice with a mix of curiosity and caution. Initially, it was likely alarmed by her intent to crush it, but upon hearing her wishes, it may have been surprised by her imaginative thinking. The remark "What a clever girl" suggests that the snail recognized her intelligence, even if it was doubtful about her understanding of compassion.

Step 3

Does the ending of this story surprise you? Why? Why not?

96%

101 rated

Answer

Yes, the ending surprises me. The shift from Melinda Alice's vivid ambitions to her morose thought of wishing she were dead is jarring. It underlines the fleeting nature of her creative aspirations and hints at deeper issues regarding her self-worth and emotional wellbeing. One would expect her to revel in her newfound power rather than spiral into despair.

Step 4

What do you think the author’s message is in this story?

98%

120 rated

Answer

The author’s message appears to revolve around the complexities of desire and the consequences of unexamined wishes. Melinda Alice's unchecked ambitions highlight the potential pitfalls of selfishness and the importance of empathy towards others. The story ultimately suggests that true fulfillment comes not just from personal gain but from a deeper understanding of oneself and one's impact on those around us.

Join the Junior Cycle students using SimpleStudy...

97% of Students

Report Improved Results

98% of Students

Recommend to friends

100,000+

Students Supported

1 Million+

Questions answered

;