Photo AI
You are participating in a debate on the motion that: ‘The use of all animals in circuses should be banned and zoos should be closed down.’ You must either agree or disagree with the motion - Junior Cycle English - Question 4 - 2018
Question 4
You are participating in a debate on the motion that: ‘The use of all animals in circuses should be banned and zoos should be closed down.’ You must either agree or ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:You are participating in a debate on the motion that: ‘The use of all animals in circuses should be banned and zoos should be closed down.’ You must either agree or disagree with the motion - Junior Cycle English - Question 4 - 2018
Step 1
Using animals for our entertainment is fundamentally cruel
Answer
One of the primary arguments against the use of wild animals in circuses is that it is inherently cruel to exploit these sentient beings for entertainment. Animals in circuses often endure confinement and harsh training methods, which can lead to psychological distress and physical harm. Studies show that such conditions are not only unnatural but can severely impact the well-being of these animals, as they are deprived of their natural behaviors and habitats. A compassionate society should prioritize the welfare of all living creatures, ensuring that they do not suffer for human amusement.
Step 2
Zoos are not natural environments
Answer
Another significant point against circuses and zoos is that they do not provide a natural environment for the animals. Many people argue that zoos serve as educational platforms about wildlife; however, it can be argued that a zoo is an artificial setting that fails to replicate the animals' natural habitats. Even the best zoo cannot mimic the complex ecological conditions of the wild, leading to issues such as captivity stress and limited behavioral expression in animals. If we truly want to educate future generations about wildlife, we should promote conservation efforts that allow animals to thrive in their natural environments rather than confining them for display.