Photo AI
1. (a) (i) Name one of your three comparative texts and identify a relationship in it - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2019
Question 1
1. (a) (i) Name one of your three comparative texts and identify a relationship in it. Use one or more key moments to explain how the characters in this relationshi... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:1. (a) (i) Name one of your three comparative texts and identify a relationship in it - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2019
Step 1
Name one of your three comparative texts and identify a relationship in it.
Answer
In my analysis, the comparative text I have chosen is The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini. The primary relationship in this text is between Amir and Hassan. This relationship shows a deep bond rooted in loyalty and betrayal, highlighting how societal classes affect their friendship.
A key moment illustrating this relationship occurs when Amir witnesses Hassan being assaulted and chooses to remain silent. This pivotal moment leads to a significant rift between the two characters, demonstrating how fear and guilt can disrupt a strong bond. Despite Amir's internal conflict, he is unable to confront his own cowardice, which ultimately leads to Hassan's alienation. In this way, the relationship is challenged by the problem of class disparity and personal weakness.
Step 2
Name another comparative text you have studied and identify a relationship in it.
Answer
Another comparative text I have studied is Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen. The central relationship in this novel is that of Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy. Initially characterized by misunderstanding and prejudice, their relationship evolves through challenges and personal growth.
A significant moment occurs when Mr. Darcy proposes to Elizabeth, but she rejects him due to his pride and her initial misjudgments. This rejection serves as a catalyst for him to reflect on his behavior and ultimately change, illustrating how personal crises can lead to growth in relationships. Their journey together, marked by challenges of societal expectations, ultimately leads to mutual respect and understanding.
Step 3
Choose a relationship from each of at least two comparative texts you have studied, and compare these relationships with reference to the main emotion evident in each.
Answer
In both The Kite Runner and Pride and Prejudice, the main emotion evident in the relationships is ultimately centered around betrayal and then growth through understanding. In The Kite Runner, the emotion of guilt fuels Amir's actions and shapes his relationship with Hassan, leading to a permanent scar in their bond. On the other hand, in Pride and Prejudice, the prevalent emotions of pride and prejudice create barriers between Elizabeth and Darcy, which they must navigate to find common ground.
As their respective stories unfold, both relationships evolve. Amir seeks redemption for his betrayal, while Elizabeth and Darcy learn to look beyond their initial misconceptions. These texts illustrate how powerful emotions can drive character development and the forging or breaking of relationships.