Photo AI
Name the text from your comparative course which describes a world that you would either like to visit or avoid - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2006
Question 1
Name the text from your comparative course which describes a world that you would either like to visit or avoid. Describe the features of that world explaining why ... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Name the text from your comparative course which describes a world that you would either like to visit or avoid - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2006
Step 1
Name the text from your comparative course which describes a world that you would either like to visit or avoid.
Answer
The text I have chosen is 'The Giver' by Lois Lowry. It describes a dystopian world where the society has eliminated all pain and suffering but at the cost of emotion and individuality. This world is a place I would avoid because it lacks the authenticity of human experience, substituting real emotions for a controlled existence.
Step 2
Describe the features of that world explaining why you find it either attractive or not.
Answer
In 'The Giver', the society is characterized by its sameness—where choices are eliminated, and people live in a monotonous routine devoid of color and emotional depth. While some might find the predictability appealing, I believe it is ultimately unattractive. The absence of joy, love, and the freedom to choose creates a sterile environment where true happiness cannot flourish. Such restrictions hinder personal growth and rob individuals of their humanity.
Step 3
Compare the world that you have just described with the world from another text you have studied on your comparative course.
Answer
In contrast, the world depicted in 'The Hunger Games' by Suzanne Collins presents a society divided by class and power struggles, where individuals must fight for their survival. This world, while dangerous and harsh, is more vibrant and filled with raw emotions compared to 'The Giver.' I find 'The Hunger Games' world more attractive despite its brutality because it showcases resilience, rebellion, and the richness of human emotions. The characters are deeply flawed yet relatable, making the world feel alive and real.
Step 4
Explain what it is about this second world that you find either more or less attractive than the one already described in (a).
Answer
'The Hunger Games' emphasizes the importance of choice, power, and the consequences of societal structures. Unlike 'The Giver', where the societal control limits personal freedom, the struggles in 'The Hunger Games' highlight themes of courage and hope amidst oppression. This active engagement with life and the fight for liberation resonates more strongly with me, illustrating the beauty of humanity's complexity, even in adversity.