“Some texts leave readers with a largely idealistic impression of a theme or issue, while others leave readers with a more realistic or believable impression of the same theme or issue.” With reference to the above statement, compare the impressions of the same theme or issue you formed when studying three texts on your comparative course - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2015

To address the impression of the same theme or issue in each of the three texts, I will focus on the portrayal of the central theme.

1. Text A: This text primarily conveys an idealistic view. The setting is overly romanticized, and the characters often exhibit behaviors that embody a perfect resolution to conflicts. This creates an impression that the theme is one that is easily resolved in the real world, leading readers to feel optimistic.

2. Text B: In contrast, Text B presents a more balanced view of the theme. It showcases both the pitfalls and the triumphs of the characters, highlighting their struggles and failures. This duality offers a more realistic impression of the theme, suggesting that real-life issues are complex and often unresolved.

3. Text C: Finally, Text C offers a bleak perspective. The author employs dark imagery and motifs that reinforce a sense of hopelessness regarding the theme. This stark representation leaves readers with a pessimistic understanding of the issue, contrasting sharply with the idealism found in Text A.