Photo AI
Based on your reading of this extract, which of the following statements do you think best describes the poet's response to the fish? - The poet admires the fish - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2013
Question 1
Based on your reading of this extract, which of the following statements do you think best describes the poet's response to the fish? - The poet admires the fish. -... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Based on your reading of this extract, which of the following statements do you think best describes the poet's response to the fish? - The poet admires the fish - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2013
Step 1
Based on your reading of this extract, which of the following statements do you think best describes the poet's response to the fish?
Answer
The poet admires the fish. In the poem, the admiration is evident through the vivid descriptions of the fish's physical appearance and its condition. For example, the phrases 'battered and venerable' suggest a sense of respect for the fish’s age and struggles. Additionally, the poet's attention to detail, such as the mentioning of 'white sea-lice' and the description of its skin, emphasizes a contemplative and fascinated response rather than one of disgust. The use of poetic devices further underlines this admiration as Bishop illustrates the beauty and complexity of the fish despite its weariness.
Step 2
Based on what you have read in the above extract, what is your own response to the fish? Explain your answer with reference to the poem.
Answer
My own response to the fish is one of admiration mixed with empathy. The depiction of the fish as 'battered' and 'venerable' resonates deeply, evoking a sense of respect for its life and experiences. As I read through the extract, I feel a connection with the struggle the fish represents. The details, such as the 'pink swim-bladder' and 'tiny white sea-lice,' conjure both fascination and concern for the fish’s well-being. These observations compel me to reflect on the themes of survival and resilience present in the poem.
Step 3
Identify one comparison in the poem that you found to be unusual or surprising and explain why you found it to be so.
Answer
One striking comparison from the poem is when the fish is likened to 'shapes like full-blown roses.' This metaphor is unusual because it juxtaposes the natural beauty associated with roses against the harsh reality of the fish's existence. While roses symbolize vitality and freshness, the context of the fish’s battered state infused with this imagery creates a deep contrast that highlights the complexities of life and beauty in decay. It is surprising as it invites the reader to reconcile the beauty found in something that is also perceived as degraded.