Photo AI

THE SISTERS BROTHERS The following text is based on an edited extract from Patrick deWitt's novel, The Sisters Brothers - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2014

Question icon

Question 1

THE-SISTERS-BROTHERS--The-following-text-is-based-on-an-edited-extract-from-Patrick-deWitt's-novel,-The-Sisters-Brothers-Leaving Cert English-Question 1-2014.png

THE SISTERS BROTHERS The following text is based on an edited extract from Patrick deWitt's novel, The Sisters Brothers. The book tells the story of two brothers, c... show full transcript

Worked Solution & Example Answer:THE SISTERS BROTHERS The following text is based on an edited extract from Patrick deWitt's novel, The Sisters Brothers - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2014

Step 1

From your reading of the above extract, what do you learn about the tooth doctor, Reginald Watts? Support your answer with reference to the text.

96%

114 rated

Answer

Reginald Watts is portrayed as a very unkind and incompetent dentist. He is described as a 'chance' or 'charlatan' who appears charming and helpful but is ultimately seen as dishonestly manipulative. He interacts with Eli in a condescending manner, demonstrating a lack of genuine care for his patients, as indicated by his comment about being happy to see someone so distorted. Furthermore, he takes a certain pride in his profession, despite his evident failures, suggesting that he is more concerned about his image than the well-being of his patients.

Step 2

Do you find Charlie’s reaction to his brother’s toothache cruel or amusing or both? Explain your answer with reference to paragraphs one and two of the above extract.

99%

104 rated

Answer

Charlie’s reaction can be seen as both amusing and cruel. Initially, his response to Eli’s swollen face is humorous; he compares Eli’s appearance to that of a dog and finds it funny. However, this humor comes across as cruel since it mocks his brother’s suffering. Further, instead of offering support, Charlie enjoys Eli’s dismay, which undermines the seriousness of Eli's condition.

Step 3

Explain, in your own words, what you think Eli Sisters means when he says: 'I laughed at the painless violence of it.'

96%

101 rated

Answer

Eli Sisters appears to be reflecting on the numbing sensation he experiences during the dental procedure, indicating a sense of absurdity regarding the violence he endures without feeling pain. It suggests an acceptance of his situation and highlights the dark humor he finds in his own suffering, correlating it with his experiences as a killer.

Step 4

Which of the two book covers above (COVER 1 or COVER 2) do you find more interesting? Explain your answer with reference to both book covers.

98%

120 rated

Answer

I find COVER 2 more interesting as it visually captures the essence of the brothers' characters through its design. The illustration of two contrasting figures gives a sense of the rivalry and complexity in their relationship. In contrast, COVER 1, while having an intriguing font, does not convey the same depth of character or narrative allure. The two figures in COVER 2 also seem to embody the tone of the novel, suggesting themes of conflict and duality.

Join the Leaving Cert students using SimpleStudy...

97% of Students

Report Improved Results

98% of Students

Recommend to friends

100,000+

Students Supported

1 Million+

Questions answered

;