Photo AI
Compare and contrast the pictures in PANEL 1 and PANEL 2 that appear on Page 6 - Leaving Cert English - Question QUESTION A – 50 Marks - 2018
Question QUESTION A – 50 Marks
Compare and contrast the pictures in PANEL 1 and PANEL 2 that appear on Page 6. Support your answer with reference only to the visual elements of the text. TEXT 3 p... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Compare and contrast the pictures in PANEL 1 and PANEL 2 that appear on Page 6 - Leaving Cert English - Question QUESTION A – 50 Marks - 2018
Step 1
Compare and contrast the pictures in PANEL 1 and PANEL 2 that appear on Page 6.
Answer
The images in PANEL 1 and PANEL 2 present differing visual narratives that evoke distinct emotional responses.
-
PANEL 1: This image is a dark, monochromatic depiction of death and destruction during World War I. The figures are shown engaged in a chaotic scene with intense action and a sense of urgency. The use of dark tones and dynamic lines contributes to a feeling of panic and fear, reinforcing the horrors of war.
-
PANEL 2: In contrast, this panel presents a more subdued, quieter scene with a soldier in a reflective pose. While it also addresses the war, its tone is more somber and introspective. The lighter color palette and the focus on the figure's expressions create an atmosphere of contemplation rather than chaos.
Thus, while both panels capture elements of war, PANEL 1 emphasizes action and terrors, whereas PANEL 2 reflects on the human experience and psychological impact of war.
Step 2
TEXT 3 presents a poetic extract in a visual format. From the poems you have studied for your Leaving Certificate course*, identify a poem, or an extract from a poem, which you think is particularly suited to presentation in a visual format.
Answer
One poem that stands out is 'The Soldier' by Rupert Brooke. I would choose to present this poem through a photographic image that captures the idyllic beauty of England, contrasting it with the themes of sacrifice in the poem.
This visual format emphasizes the pastoral imagery found in the text, representing what the soldier fights for. The juxtaposition of the image against the poem's themes can create a powerful impact, highlighting the irony of glorious death for one's country.
Step 3
Based on your reading of the material on Page 6 of TEXT 3, do you agree that the combination of poetry and illustration, found in the text, is extremely effective in amplifying and extending the meaning of the poem and adding to the overall impact of the text?
Answer
Yes, I concur that the integration of poetry and illustration serves to enhance the meaning significantly. The visual elements in PANEL 1 amplify the emotional weight by graphically displaying the chaos of war, which aligns with the poet's message of despair and destruction.
In PANEL 2, the more subdued illustration adds depth to the exploration of the soldier's psyche, making the viewer reflect on the internal struggles faced by those in war. Together, both panels create a holistic portrayal that extends beyond the written word, allowing the audience to grasp the gravity of the themes presented.