Photo AI
Describe an occasion from the text when you think Kate Keller is unkind to Ann Deever - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2018
Question 1
Describe an occasion from the text when you think Kate Keller is unkind to Ann Deever. In your opinion, is Kate generally unkind to Ann? Explain your answer with re... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Describe an occasion from the text when you think Kate Keller is unkind to Ann Deever - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2018
Step 1
Describe an occasion from the text when you think Kate Keller is unkind to Ann Deever.
Answer
In Arthur Miller's play, Kate Keller demonstrates unkindness towards Ann Deever when she confronts Ann about her relationship with Chris. For example, during a heated discussion, Kate insists that Ann's presence is inappropriate because of her doubts about Chris's future. At one point, she states, "You’re not going to marry him. You know that, don’t you darling?" This statement not only dismisses Ann's feelings but also undermines her hopes and desires.
Step 2
In your opinion, is Kate generally unkind to Ann? Explain your answer with reference to the text.
Answer
In my opinion, Kate is generally unkind to Ann. Throughout the play, she exhibits a consistent pattern of behavior that reflects her jealousy and suspicion towards Ann’s intentions. For instance, during the breakfast scene in Act 1, Kate accuses Ann of trying to replace Larry, thus projecting her fears onto Ann. This lack of empathy shows Kate's inability to recognize Ann as her own person, leading her to express hostility towards Ann.
Step 3
Identify a moment in the play, All My Sons, which you find particularly dramatic or exciting. Explain what makes this moment so dramatic or exciting.
Answer
A particularly dramatic moment in the play occurs when George shows up at the Keller household. His arrival creates a palpable tension that escalates and reveals long-buried secrets. The emotional stakes rise as George confronts Chris about the cylinders, causing Chris to grapple with his father's actions. This confrontation is significant not only for its suspense but also for its exploration of betrayal and truth, effectively drawing the audience into the precarious situation.
Step 4
Write about the importance of either loyalty or betrayal in the play, All My Sons. Support your response with reference to the text.
Answer
Betrayal is a central theme in All My Sons, particularly illustrated through Joe Keller’s actions. His decision to ship faulty airplane parts led to the deaths of 21 pilots, including his son Larry. Joe's betrayal of societal and familial trust poses profound moral questions, culminating in the tragic outcomes for the Keller family. This highlights the immense impact of personal choices and ethical dilemmas on relationships, making betrayal a pivotal element of the narrative.
Step 5
From the list below, choose the phrase or phrases that best describe(s) your overall response to the play, All My Sons.
Answer
I found the play disturbing. The unraveling of family dynamics and the moral conflicts presented in the text elicit a discomforting reflection on the consequences of one’s actions.
Step 6
You have been asked to show your class three objects that you think help to reveal something about the life or personality of one of the following characters from the play, All My Sons: Joe Keller or Ann Deever.
Answer
- A set of broken airplane parts: This represents Joe Keller's moral failure and the consequences of his actions, indicating the betrayal of his employees and society.
- A family photograph: This signifies the idealized family Joe desires, contrasting sharply with the fractured reality that exists.
- A newspaper clipping about the war: This illustrates the external pressures and decisions that influenced Joe’s actions, further revealing his internal conflict and justification.