Photo AI
1. Give two pieces of evidence from the play to show that life is sometimes difficult for Gert Polpin - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2016
Question 1
1. Give two pieces of evidence from the play to show that life is sometimes difficult for Gert Polpin. 2. (a) Do you think that Maggie Polpin has a mainly positive... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:1. Give two pieces of evidence from the play to show that life is sometimes difficult for Gert Polpin - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2016
Step 1
Give two pieces of evidence from the play to show that life is sometimes difficult for Gert Polpin.
Answer
In John B. Keane's play, "Big Maggie", two significant pieces of evidence highlight the difficulties faced by Gert Polpin:
-
Isolation and Neglect: Gert experiences emotional neglect from her family, especially from her daughter, Maggie. There are moments where Maggie's ambitions overshadow Gert's needs, leaving her feeling isolated within her own household. This reflects a common theme in the play where personal aspirations conflict with family obligations, leading to Gert’s emotional struggles.
-
Financial Strain: The financial challenges are evident in how Gert is burdened by the lack of support from her family regarding the upkeep of the farm. This economic pressure complicates her daily life, affecting her mental well-being and overall happiness, showcasing how financial difficulties can steer familial relationships into turbulent waters.
Step 2
(a) Do you think that Maggie Polpin has a mainly positive or a mainly negative impact on her son, Maurice? Give one reason for your answer.
Answer
I believe that Maggie Polpin has a mainly negative impact on her son, Maurice. While she may have good intentions, her relentless drive for control and ambition often overshadows Maurice’s individual needs and desires. For example, her push for him to engage in the family business and to take on responsibilities at a young age leads to pressure that negatively affects his self-esteem and personal identity.
Step 3
(b) Name a character from the play who you think disapproves of Maggie's behaviour towards Maurice. Explain why you think this character disapproves of Maggie's behaviour.
Answer
A character who disapproves of Maggie's behaviour towards Maurice is Kate, Maggie's mother. Kate expresses concern over how Maggie places immense pressure on Maurice, often treating him as a pawn in her ambitions. She believes that Maggie's actions are detrimental to Maurice's mental health and that he needs more nurturing and freedom to develop into his own person. Kate's disapproval stems from her protective instincts towards her grandson, as she recalls the innocence of childhood and fears Maggie is robbing Maurice of that by imposing adult responsibilities on him too soon.