Photo AI
1. (a) Describe the relationship between Nan Mahon and her mother - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2017
Question 1
1. (a) Describe the relationship between Nan Mahon and her mother. Support your answer with reference to the text. (b) Explain why you do or do not admire Nan Mahon... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:1. (a) Describe the relationship between Nan Mahon and her mother - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2017
Step 1
Describe the relationship between Nan Mahon and her mother.
Answer
The relationship between Nan Mahon and her mother is characterized by a nuanced blend of closeness and conflict. Nan's mother is supportive yet also imposes high expectations on her. This duality of support and pressure creates a complex dynamic where Nan seeks approval while simultaneously yearning for independence. Their relationship reflects typical mother-daughter tensions, particularly in the context of longing for personal identity.
Step 2
Explain why you do or do not admire Nan Mahon.
Answer
I do admire Nan Mahon because she embodies resilience and ambition. Despite facing societal pressures, she strives for her own identity and stands up for her beliefs. However, her moments of selfishness—particularly in her dealings with Jack and Benny—highlight her flaws, making her a relatable, multifaceted character. This complexity invites admiration as she navigates her world.
Step 3
Identify one episode or incident in the novel, Circle of Friends, which you find shocking or surprising.
Answer
One shocking incident in the novel is when a secret about Benny's family emerges, revealing the extent of societal judgment and personal betrayal they endure. This moment starkly illustrates the harsh realities faced by individuals and the impact of external perceptions on personal relationships. It forces readers to confront the often hidden struggles within seemingly ordinary lives.
Step 4
Imagine you are a journalist, writing for a popular magazine. You have interviewed Benny Hogan after she moves to Dublin. Write an article giving your impression of Benny and telling your readers how she feels about her new life in Dublin.
Answer
Benny Hogan, a spirited and optimistic character, exudes excitement as she navigates her new life in Dublin. In our recent conversation, she shared her impression of the city as vibrant and full of potential. Despite initial challenges, Benny embraces her new surroundings with open arms, establishing friendships that bring her joy. Her determination to thrive amidst change showcases her resilience and hope for the future.
Step 5
In your opinion, which of the following observations is more accurate?
Answer
In my opinion, the female characters in the novel are more fascinating than the male characters. Characters like Nan and Benny provide deep insights into feminine struggles and triumphs in a male-dominated society. Their stories resonate with emotional depth and complexity, illuminating the challenges they face and their relationships, making them central to the narrative's richness.
Step 6
To what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
Answer
I agree with the statement that Maeve Binchy's novel, Circle of Friends, remains relevant today. Despite its 1950s setting, its exploration of friendship, societal expectations, and gender roles resonates with contemporary readers. Binchy addresses timeless themes of love, betrayal, and personal growth, ensuring the novel's enduring impact and connection to modern issues faced by individuals in society.