Photo AI
1. Give two pieces of evidence from the novel to show that life is sometimes difficult for Hareton Earnshaw - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2016
Question 1
1. Give two pieces of evidence from the novel to show that life is sometimes difficult for Hareton Earnshaw. 2. (a) Do you think that Catherine Earnshaw has a mainl... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:1. Give two pieces of evidence from the novel to show that life is sometimes difficult for Hareton Earnshaw - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2016
Step 1
Give two pieces of evidence from the novel to show that life is sometimes difficult for Hareton Earnshaw.
Answer
Hareton Earnshaw faces numerous challenges throughout the novel, particularly stemming from his upbringing.
-
Lack of Education: Hareton is denied an education due to Hindley's abusive nature, which limits his social mobility and personal development. He is treated like a servant in his own home, emphasizing his isolation and the difficulty of his circumstances. This is evident when Heathcliff tells Hareton that he is the 'lowest of the low' when it comes to being educated, showcasing the harshness of his reality.
-
Emotional Struggles: Hareton's relationships with his family and Heathcliff create an emotionally tumultuous environment. The constant reminders of his mother's disdain toward him and the lack of affection from his father only serve to deepen his struggles. For example, after the death of his father, Hareton is left feeling unloved and neglected, indicating how life’s difficulties have shaped his character.
Step 2
Do you think that Catherine Earnshaw has a mainly positive or a mainly negative impact on Heathcliff? Give one reason for your answer.
Answer
Catherine Earnshaw has a mainly negative impact on Heathcliff. While their bond is intense, Catherine's decisions often lead to Heathcliff's suffering. For instance, her choice to marry Edgar Linton for social status leaves Heathcliff feeling betrayed and abandoned. This pivotal moment drives Heathcliff into a rage that ultimately results in his desire for revenge, shaping the narrative's tragic trajectory.
Step 3
Name a character from the novel that disapproves of the relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine Earnshaw. Explain why this character disapproves of this relationship.
Answer
One character who disapproves of the relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine is Edgar Linton. Edgar's disapproval stems from his belief that Heathcliff is of a lower social class and therefore unworthy of Catherine's affection. He sees Heathcliff as a threat to his idealized vision of a respectable life with Catherine. Edgar's view is rooted in the societal norms of the time, which emphasize social status and class, thus making him a staunch opponent to their passionate relationship.
Step 4
‘Social class is important in the novel Wuthering Heights.’ Do you agree or disagree with the above statement? Give reasons for your answer, demonstrating your knowledge of the text.
Answer
I agree that social class is of paramount importance in 'Wuthering Heights.' The characters' interactions and fates are deeply influenced by their social standings, significantly affecting their relationships and life choices. For instance, Catherine's marriage to Edgar Linton is a direct consequence of her desire to elevate her social status, which ultimately leads to her emotional turmoil and Heathcliff's vengeful transformation. The class distinctions create barriers that characters struggle to overcome, such as Hindley's disdain for Heathcliff due to his orphaned status, which drives much of the conflict in the narrative.
Step 5
You have been asked to recommend a novel to your school Book Club. Explain why you would or would not recommend Wuthering Heights to the Book Club readers. Your recommendation should demonstrate your knowledge of the novel.
Answer
I would recommend 'Wuthering Heights' to my school Book Club due to its complex themes and character development. The novel explores deep emotional and psychological issues, such as obsession and revenge, set against the dramatic backdrop of the Yorkshire moors. Its rich, gothic elements and the tumultuous relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine provoke thoughtful discussions about love and morality. However, I would caution the readers about its dark themes and complex narrative, which may not be suitable for everyone.
Step 6
Imagine that you are Edgar Linton. Write two diary entries: one dealing with your wedding to Catherine Earnshaw and another giving your reaction to Heathcliff’s return. Your diary entries should demonstrate your knowledge of the novel.
Answer
Dear Diary,
Today was the most significant day of my life—my wedding to Catherine Earnshaw. The ceremony was beautiful, yet I sensed a shadow lingering, an undercurrent of tumultuous feelings. Catherine seemed radiant, but in her eyes, I could perceive remnants of her past with Heathcliff. I am aware of her deep connection with him, which stirs unease within me. Still, I convince myself that my love and status provide her with stability and respect, qualities I believe will nurture our future together.
Dear Diary,
Heathcliff has returned, and my heart is heavy with foreboding. His presence feels like a storm on the horizon, threatening the peace I had hoped would envelop my marriage. The way Catherine's eyes light up at the mere mention of his name fills me with jealousy and dread. I fear that his return will reignite old passions, unraveling the bond I share with Catherine. The tension in our household is palpable, and I can't shake the feeling that he will disrupt our lives once more.