Photo AI
What reasons for marrying Edgar Linton does Catherine Earnshaw give to Nelly Dean? Do you think that Catherine should have married Heathcliff? Give one reason for your answer - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2011
Question 1
What reasons for marrying Edgar Linton does Catherine Earnshaw give to Nelly Dean? Do you think that Catherine should have married Heathcliff? Give one reason f... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:What reasons for marrying Edgar Linton does Catherine Earnshaw give to Nelly Dean? Do you think that Catherine should have married Heathcliff? Give one reason for your answer - Leaving Cert English - Question 1 - 2011
Step 1
What reasons for marrying Edgar Linton does Catherine Earnshaw give to Nelly Dean?
Answer
Catherine Earnshaw provides several reasons for her decision to marry Edgar Linton. She describes Edgar as 'handsome' and 'pleasant to be with,' which highlights his appealing physical attributes and amiable demeanor. Additionally, she comments on his status and wealth, stating that these factors also play a significant role in her choice. Though she is deeply in love with Heathcliff, she recognizes that marriage to him would lead to a life marked by poverty and degradation. This juxtaposition reveals her struggle between love and social ambition, as she feels compelled to choose a path that ensures her material comfort and social standing.
Step 2
Do you think that Catherine should have married Heathcliff? Give one reason for your answer.
Answer
Yes, I believe Catherine should have married Heathcliff because her emotional connection with him is profound and authentic. She expresses that she 'cannot live without my life, without my soul,' indicating the deep bond they share. In contrast, her marriage to Edgar is more about societal expectations and material gain than true love, causing her emotional turmoil and contributing to her eventual downfall.
Step 3
What is your opinion of Isabella Linton? Explain your answer.
Answer
Isabella Linton is a complex character whose actions and choices often elicit mixed feelings. Initially, she appears to be influenced heavily by romantic ideals, particularly in her infatuation with Heathcliff. However, her decision to marry him demonstrates naivety and a lack of understanding of his true nature. Over time, she becomes a victim of Heathcliff's cruelty, which illustrates the darker side of romantic desire. Ultimately, my opinion of Isabella is that she is a tragic figure caught in a web of her own misguided choices, which lead to her suffering and disillusionment.