Photo AI
Technology can only go so far in helping officials, and at times it can make officiating more difficult - Leaving Cert Physical Education - Question 3 - 2021
Question 3
Technology can only go so far in helping officials, and at times it can make officiating more difficult. Discuss this statement.
Worked Solution & Example Answer:Technology can only go so far in helping officials, and at times it can make officiating more difficult - Leaving Cert Physical Education - Question 3 - 2021
Step 1
Discuss the Positive Impact of Technology on Officiating
Answer
Technology has significantly enhanced the abilities of officials in various sports. For example, the introduction of video assistant referees (VAR) in football allows referees to review key decisions. This has contributed to more accurate calls regarding goals and penalties. Additionally, technologies like Hawk-Eye in tennis help in making precise line calls, which improves the fairness of the game.
Moreover, technology can reduce the pressure on officials, providing them with tools to make informed decisions. Improvements in communication devices also facilitate better coordination among officiating teams.
Step 2
Discuss the Limitations of Technology in Officiating
Answer
Despite the advantages, technology also presents challenges. One major issue is the delay caused by video reviews, which can disrupt the flow of the game and cause frustration among players and fans. In some cases, lengthy reviews can lead to confusion rather than clarity.
Moreover, reliance on technology can diminish the authority of officiating crews. Players may question human judgment when they feel that technology provides a contradicting perspective, potentially undermining the officials' credibility.
Step 3
Conclusion on the Role of Technology
Answer
In conclusion, while technology serves as a valuable tool that can improve officiating, it also has inherent limitations that can complicate the role of officials. The challenge lies in finding a balance where technology complements human decision-making without overshadowing it. Ultimately, the effectiveness of technology in officiating depends on its implementation and the ability of officials to adapt to its presence.