Issues Related to the Development of Christianity Pre-1945 (HSC SSCE Studies of Religion): Revision Notes
Issues Related to the Development of Christianity Pre-1945
Introduction
Two significant issues shaped the development of Christianity in Australia from early settlement until 1945: sectarianism and the need for social welfare. These issues emerged during the earliest days of European settlement and profoundly influenced Australian society, politics, and religious life for over a century.
Understanding these issues is essential for grasping how Christianity developed in Australia and how religious divisions affected everyday life. Both issues reveal the complex relationship between religion, politics, and social structures in pre-1945 Australia.
These two issues were not isolated phenomena but were deeply interconnected with Australia's colonial history, immigration patterns, and the gradual formation of Australian identity. They demonstrate how religious institutions shaped both social policy and everyday interactions in Australian society.
Sectarianism
What was sectarianism?
Sectarianism refers to excessive devotion to a particular sect or religious faith, coupled with a belief in the absolute rightness of one's own religious group. In the Australian context, sectarianism primarily manifested as deep division between Catholics and Protestants.
The definition can be expanded as: belief in its own sense of rightness by a particular subgroup of a society. This involved not merely religious difference but active discrimination and social separation between religious communities.
Origins and causes of sectarianism
Sectarianism in Australia did not emerge in isolation. It had clear historical roots in conflicts that predated Australian settlement:
Irish-English conflict: The primary source was the centuries-old antagonism between the Church of England and Irish Catholics in Ireland. This bitter religious and political conflict was transplanted to Australia through immigration patterns.
Protestant divisions: Conflict also existed within Protestantism itself. Church of England adherents in England held prejudices against non-conformist churches (Protestant denominations that did not conform to Anglican practices). These internal Protestant tensions also shaped Australian religious life.
Sectarianism reflected not only religious differences but also political, cultural, linguistic, and ethnic divisions. The English-Irish antagonism was as much about nationality, culture, and politics as it was about theology.
How sectarianism affected Australian society
Sectarian division created a society split along clearly defined religious lines. The practical effects touched every aspect of daily life:
Social segregation: Catholics and Protestants did not enter each other's churches and rarely intermarried. Religious communities remained largely separate, with minimal social interaction between them.
Employment discrimination: Job advertisements openly stated 'Catholics need not apply'. This blatant discrimination limited career opportunities for Catholic Australians, regardless of their qualifications or abilities.
This form of discrimination was not hidden or subtle—it was openly advertised in newspapers and accepted as normal business practice. Employers felt no social or legal pressure to hide their religious preferences in hiring.
Class divisions: Despite Australia's reputation as an egalitarian society, sectarianism reinforced class boundaries. Catholics were generally less educated and working class, whilst Protestants tended to be more educated and middle class. This pattern reflected and reinforced existing social inequalities.
Educational disadvantage: Limited educational opportunities for Catholics contributed to their lower socio-economic status, creating a cycle of disadvantage that persisted for generations.
Case study: Daniel Mannix and the conscription debate
Background on Daniel Mannix
Daniel Mannix (1864-1963) became the most prominent figure in Australian sectarian politics during the early twentieth century. His life and career illustrate how religious leaders could shape national debates:
- Born in Ireland, ordained as a priest in 1890
- Sent to Australia in 1912 as assistant to the Archbishop of Melbourne
- Became Archbishop of Melbourne in 1917
- Cemented Irish Catholic unity in Australia
- Known supporter of Irish independence
- Strongly opposed violence, even when perpetrated by fellow Catholics for Irish causes
Mannix represented a powerful subgroup within Australian society. His influence demonstrated how Catholicism, anti-British sentiment, and nationalism intertwined in early twentieth-century Australia.
The conscription crisis of 1916
When Australia entered World War I in 1914, Archbishop Mannix remained ambivalent about the conflict. This stance contrasted sharply with many Protestant ministers who urged their congregations to support the war effort 'at all costs'.
Background to the referendum: The war devastated Britain, which placed enormous pressure on Australia to send more troops. Prime Minister William (Billy) Hughes (1862-1952) initially promised in 1915 that there would be no conscription (a legal act by government forcing citizens to enlist in defence forces for war service). However, mounting casualties led Hughes to reverse his position.
The 1916 referendum: Hughes held a national referendum to determine whether Australians supported conscription. The vote was narrowly defeated, with Mannix serving as Hughes's main opponent. The Archbishop's opposition carried significant weight within the Catholic community.
Hughes deliberately exploited sectarian differences and endorsed an anti-Catholic agenda during the conscription campaign. This tactic deepened religious divisions and politicised sectarianism further.
Catholics and accusations of disloyalty
During World War I, Australian Catholics faced widespread suspicion of disloyalty to Australia and the British Empire. Several factors intensified these suspicions:
The 1916 Easter Rising: When Ireland rebelled against British rule in Dublin's Easter Rising, Australian Catholics came under increased scrutiny. The rebellion reinforced stereotypes about Catholic disloyalty to the Crown.
The Jerger case: Father Charles Jerger, a priest of German background, was interned in 1918 for publicly discussing conscription. He was subsequently deported in 1920. This case exemplified the severe consequences Catholics could face for expressing views that challenged the war effort.
The 'ghetto' community: Critics claimed that Irish Catholics formed the first 'ghetto' ethnic community in Australia. This accusation suggested Catholics remained separate and unassimilated, more loyal to their faith and ethnicity than to their adopted nation.
Anti-Catholic feeling was often subtle and embedded in everyday life, but occasionally erupted into public view during crises like the conscription debate. This pattern of underlying tension punctuated by public conflict characterized sectarianism throughout the period.
Broader opposition to conscription
Exam tip: When discussing the conscription referendums, avoid oversimplifying the result as purely Catholic opposition. This demonstrates analytical depth.
It is crucial to note that Catholics were not alone in opposing conscription. Many other Christian groups, especially Methodists, also opposed forced military service. The referendum was lost by a margin much greater than the Catholic vote alone could account for. This broader opposition reflected widespread Australian reluctance to accept conscription, transcending sectarian divisions.
Historical perspective
The idea that an archbishop could influence national politics so decisively may seem implausible today. However, in an era of deep sectarian division, religious leaders wielded enormous political influence.
Catholicism, anti-British sentiment, and Australian nationalism formed interconnected parts of a general social outlook that gave figures like Mannix considerable power. Religious identity was not simply a private spiritual matter but a comprehensive framework that shaped political views, social relationships, and national allegiances.
The decline of sectarianism
Post-war changes
By 1945, Australia's population stood at approximately eight million people. The Japanese attacks on Sydney Harbour and Darwin during World War II forced politicians and bureaucrats to confront Australia's vulnerability. Such a small population could not effectively defend such a vast continent.
Immigration programs: From 1945 onwards, successive governments implemented large-scale immigration programs:
- The Chifley Labor government initiated the program
- Robert Menzies' conservative Liberal government continued and expanded it
- The influx of new migrants from diverse backgrounds gradually diluted sectarian divisions
Factors contributing to sectarianism's demise
Several interconnected factors led to the gradual death of sectarianism as a major social division:
Increased diversity: Post-war immigration brought people from many European nations, creating a more diverse religious landscape that could not be contained within a simple Catholic-Protestant binary.
Broader perspectives: Australians who served overseas during World War II returned with expanded worldviews and greater awareness of diversity. These experiences made sectarian divisions seem parochial and outdated.
Government aid to church schools: State funding of religious schools reduced some of the educational disadvantages Catholics faced, narrowing the class gap between Catholic and Protestant communities.
Government funding for church schools was itself controversial and took decades to implement fully. The debate over state aid to religious schools became a major political issue, but ultimately the policy helped reduce one of the key structural causes of sectarian inequality.
The ALP split: The split within the Australian Labor Party during the 1950s over attitudes toward communism paradoxically helped reduce sectarianism by fragmenting traditional Catholic-Labor political alignments.
Changing attitudes to religion: General shifts in Australian attitudes toward religion, including increasing secularisation, made sectarian divisions less relevant to many people's lives.
Timeline of decline
Whilst sectarianism began to decline after 1945, its effects persisted for decades. The most significant sectarian attitudes lingered until the 1970s, when they finally became largely obsolete in mainstream Australian society.
Exam guidance: When evaluating the impact of sectarianism, consider both its duration (from settlement to 1970s) and its gradual decline rather than sudden disappearance. This nuanced understanding demonstrates sophisticated historical thinking.
Social welfare
Why churches provided social welfare
In early colonial Australia, the government took no responsibility for social welfare provision. This absence of state support created an urgent need that religious communities stepped in to fill. Church involvement was not merely helpful but desperately needed in a vast country where governments struggled to provide basic services.
Christianity and charity: Christianity, like many other religions, places charity and social conscience at the centre of its teachings and activities. Christians can be generous and open-hearted when offering support to those in need. This theological imperative drove extensive church involvement in welfare work.
The welfare vacuum: Today, welfare is predominantly provided by the state through government programs and payments. This was emphatically not the case in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Support for people who could not work, or who were disabled or disadvantaged, came almost entirely from community sources. These sources were mainly religious organisations.
Problems with church-based welfare
Despite churches' good intentions, significant problems emerged with religiously-provided social welfare:
The belonging problem: Questions about church membership created difficulties, particularly during the Great Depression of the 1930s. Although many people desperately needed assistance, churches often prioritised their own members when distributing limited resources.
Sectarian divisions in welfare: Just as sectarianism divided Australian society generally, it also affected welfare provision. Catholic organisations primarily served Catholics, Protestant organisations served Protestants, and so on. This division meant some people in need might be excluded based on their religious affiliation or lack thereof.
Resource limitations: During severe economic crises like the Great Depression, even well-intentioned churches lacked the resources to meet overwhelming need. This limitation eventually forced government intervention.
Key welfare organizations
Benevolent Society of New South Wales
The Benevolent Society represents one of Australia's earliest and most significant social welfare initiatives:
Establishment: Founded by Edward Smith Hall in 1813, it was originally named 'The NSW Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge and Benevolence'. The organization changed its name in 1817 to the Benevolent Society of New South Wales.
Pioneering work: The Society is best known for building Australia's first maternity hospital, addressing a critical need for women's healthcare in the colony.
Progressive advocacy: Beyond direct service provision, the Benevolent Society was heavily involved in lobbying for a range of progressive social reforms. This advocacy work helped shape government policy on social issues.
Focus areas: The organization concentrated its efforts on women and children, whilst also assisting the elderly and the poor. This focus reflected both genuine need and prevailing social attitudes about who deserved charitable support.
St Vincent de Paul Society
The St Vincent de Paul Society brought international Catholic charitable work to Australia:
International origins: Founded in France in 1833 by Frédéric Ozanam, the Society emerged during turbulent times in French history. It was designed to assist the poor and less fortunate who had suffered during political and social upheaval.
Catholic identification: The Society is firmly identified with Roman Catholicism, reflecting the Church's emphasis on charitable work and social justice.
Australian establishment: The Australian branch began in 1854, twenty-one years after the French establishment. This relatively quick expansion demonstrates the Society's effectiveness and appeal.
Rapid growth: By 1895, twenty-six bases had been established in Sydney alone, showing both the extent of need and the Society's organizational capacity.
The St Vincent de Paul Society became, and remains, strongly identified with a caring Catholic Church. It represents one of the most visible expressions of Catholic social teaching in action.
The Salvation Army
The Salvation Army represents a unique approach to combining evangelical Christianity with social welfare:
Founder: William Booth, a former Methodist minister, established the organization in London. His background in Methodism influenced the Army's evangelical emphasis and organizational structure.
Purpose: Booth aimed to make both assistance and religion more accessible to people living in slums. This dual focus distinguished the Salvation Army from purely charitable or purely evangelical organizations.
Timeline: Whilst Booth's work began in 1865, the name 'The Salvation Army' was not adopted until 1878. The military-style name reflected the organization's disciplined, hierarchical structure.
Spiritual and practical focus: The Salvation Army amalgamated spiritual concerns with practical welfare and charity work. This combination aimed to address both the material and spiritual needs of struggling lower classes and homeless people.
Australian beginnings: The first Salvation Army meeting in Australia took place on 5 September 1880, bringing this innovative approach to welfare and evangelism to the colonies.
'No strings attached' approach: The Salvation Army gained particular respect because it reached out to people in need without requiring religious conversion or church attendance as a condition for assistance. This approach contrasted with some other religious welfare providers.
Widespread acceptance: Because of its unconditional service, the Salvation Army was accepted by many Australians who would normally reject traditional churches. It built bridges across sectarian and class divides.
Depression-era work: During the Great Depression, the Salvation Army ran soup kitchens and provided emergency assistance, offering literal survival support to desperate people.
Other welfare groups
Numerous other Christian organizations became involved in social welfare provision, though many were initially more regional or state-based rather than national:
Anglican organizations: The Sydney Home Mission Society (which later became part of Anglicare) provided welfare services within the Anglican tradition. Anglicare is now a national network of care and social justice agencies of the Anglican Church in Australia.
Methodist initiatives: The Wesley Central Mission offered welfare services connected to Methodist theology and community structures.
Mission Australia: This organization grew to become one of Australia's largest providers of family and community services.
Brotherhood of St Laurence: Based in Melbourne, this Church of England organization focused on poverty relief and social justice advocacy.
Expansion pattern: Many of these organizations began as regional initiatives but became national organizations toward the end of the twentieth century, reflecting both growing need and improved organizational capacity.
Broader church welfare involvement
Churches did not limit their welfare work to direct poverty relief:
Education provision: Christian churches established extensive school systems, providing education particularly to communities that might otherwise lack access. These schools served both religious and social welfare functions.
Medical care: Churches built and operated hospitals, clinics, and other medical facilities. In remote areas, church-run medical services were often the only healthcare available.
Friendly Societies: These member-based mutual aid organizations, often connected to churches, helped their members in times of need through a form of community insurance.
Government involvement in welfare
For much of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the government avoided involvement in social welfare provision. This changed gradually due to economic crises:
Economic depressions: The economic depressions of the 1890s and 1930s created such widespread need that churches alone could not cope. These crises forced government intervention.
1940s welfare state: It was not until the 1940s that government payments such as unemployment benefits and sickness benefits were introduced. This marked the beginning of Australia's modern welfare state.
Continuing church role: Despite increased government involvement, many Christian organizations continue to provide social welfare services today. Some now receive government funding whilst maintaining their religious identity and mission.
Partnership model: Contemporary welfare provision often involves partnerships between government funding and church-based service delivery, combining resources from both sectors.
Remember!
Key points to remember:
-
Sectarianism was the major religious division in pre-1945 Australia, primarily between Catholics and Protestants, rooted in Irish-English conflict and affecting employment, education, marriage, and social class.
-
Daniel Mannix (Archbishop of Melbourne 1917-1963) led Catholic opposition to conscription during World War I, becoming a focal point for sectarian politics and demonstrating the political power of religious leaders.
-
Sectarianism's decline began after 1945 due to post-war immigration, increased diversity, government aid to church schools, and changing social attitudes, though effects lingered until the 1970s.
-
Church-based social welfare was essential in colonial and early twentieth-century Australia because governments provided no welfare support, with churches filling this gap through organizations like the Benevolent Society, St Vincent de Paul Society, and Salvation Army.
-
Government welfare involvement only began seriously during the economic depressions of the 1890s and 1930s, with unemployment and sickness benefits not introduced until the 1940s.
Key terms
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Sectarianism | Excessive devotion to a particular sect or religious faith; belief in the absolute rightness of one's own religious group |
| Conscription | A legal act by government forcing citizens to enlist in defence forces, mainly for war service |
| Anglicare | National network of care and social justice agencies of the Anglican Church in Australia |
| Great Depression | Severe worldwide economic depression of the 1930s that created massive unemployment and poverty |
| Non-conformist churches | Protestant denominations that did not conform to Church of England practices |
| Social welfare | Support and assistance for people who cannot work or are disadvantaged, including healthcare, housing, and financial aid |
Exam technique tips
For 'describe' questions: Focus on specific features and characteristics. When describing sectarianism, mention concrete examples like employment discrimination ('Catholics need not apply') and social segregation (no intermarriage).
For 'explain' questions: Identify causes and effects. When explaining why sectarianism developed, link it clearly to Irish-English conflict and show how it affected different aspects of Australian society.
For 'assess' or 'evaluate' questions: Weigh up different factors and reach a judgement. When assessing why sectarianism declined, consider multiple factors (immigration, education, changing attitudes) and evaluate which were most significant.
Using case studies: Daniel Mannix and the conscription debate provides a detailed case study. In exam answers, use specific details (dates like 1916 referendum, events like Easter Rising, individuals like Father Jerger) to support your arguments and demonstrate detailed knowledge.