Creating Your Responses: Planning, Drafting, and Editing (VCE SSCE English): Revision Notes
Creating Your Responses: Planning, Drafting, and Editing
Understanding the writing process
Creating effective written responses requires moving through several distinct stages. The complete writing process includes prewriting, drafting, revising, editing and publishing. Each stage plays a crucial role in developing your work, and missing any of them can weaken your final response.
Prewriting is particularly important as it helps you generate and organise your ideas before you commit to specific decisions about the form and structure of your piece. Think of it as laying the groundwork for everything that follows.
Planning your writing
Careful planning before you start writing helps you organise your ideas, structure your writing effectively and avoid writer's block. The planning stage involves three key phases: prewriting, planning and outlining.
Prewriting
During prewriting, you lay the foundation for your response by:
- Defining the purpose and audience of your response
- Brainstorming to generate a range of ideas
- Organising your ideas into categories or themes
- Using graphic organisers or other tools to visualise your ideas
- Identifying any research or additional information you may need
Planning
Once you have generated initial ideas, the planning phase involves:
- Reviewing your prewriting notes and selecting the most important or interesting ideas
- Choosing an appropriate form for your response
- Following up on any additional research or sources you may need
- Determining the structure of your response and the order in which you will present ideas
- Considering the language, style and tone that will be most appropriate for your form, purpose, context and audience
Outlining
Creating a detailed outline helps ensure your response is clear and coherent:
- Identify what you will include in the introduction, body and conclusion. For an imaginative text such as a short story, think about how you will begin, what will happen at the climax and how you will resolve tension. If your response is in a form such as poetry, consider how you will structure your poem or collection of poems.
- Create headings and subheadings to organise your content. You might not include these in the final piece, but they will help your writing stay focused.
- Ensure your outline follows a clear and logical order
- Check that the ending of your text will be effective and appropriate to the form, such as a resolution of tension in a short story, a clear statement of conclusions in an essay, or a call to action in a persuasive piece
- Review your outline to ensure that it reflects your purpose and audience
Brainstorming and graphic organisers
One of the most effective prewriting strategies is brainstorming. This technique allows you to generate numerous ideas quickly and organise them into categories or themes. Using a graphic organiser, such as a mind map or concept map, helps you visualise your ideas and understand their relationships.
Worked Example: Brainstorming with a Mind Map
When brainstorming ideas about personal experiences of living in the country, you might place your central focus in the middle of the page, then arrange related thoughts around the outside. Your mind map could include:
- Childhood memories
- Rural lifestyle
- Cultural traditions
- Conservation issues
- Important figures and people
- Questions for further exploration (such as how has the area changed? what are the challenges?)
- Possible forms (memoir, travel essay, reflective essay)
After generating your ideas through brainstorming:
- Review your notes and select the most important ideas
- Organise your selected ideas into logical groups or themes
- Arrange these groups into a logical sequence, considering how you will begin, what will be in the main body, and how you will end
- Create a detailed outline including headings and subheadings
Drafting your response
During the drafting process, focus on using narrative techniques and language features to make your writing effective and engaging. Developing your voice is crucial, as it helps your writing stand out and connect with your reader. Additionally, incorporating feedback from others during drafting will improve the clarity and coherence of your writing.
Language features for effective writing
The effective use of language features makes a text more engaging, informative and memorable. Here are four key techniques to incorporate into your writing:
Imagery: Using vivid descriptions to create mental images, often appealing to one or more of the five senses (sight, sound, smell, taste and touch).
The sky was a canvas painted with shades of orange and pink.
This sentence uses imagery and metaphor to describe the sunset and create an image in the reader's mind, helping them visualise the scene and connect with the writer's experience.
Figurative language: Using non-literal language such as hyperbole, metaphors, similes and personification to add layers of meaning.
Her words were like a knife, cutting deep into my soul.
This simile conveys the emotional impact of the words effectively in a personal essay exploring a difficult emotional experience.
Varied sentence structures: Using different types of sentences (simple, compound, complex) to create flow and rhythm. Short, sharp sentences can have dramatic impact, especially after longer, more complex sentences.
Suddenly, the lights went out.
This brief sentence can shift the tone or signal a change in direction.
Varied punctuation: Using punctuation to create emphasis, drama, suspense and so on. In dialogue, dashes and ellipses (...) can indicate pauses, hesitation and uncertainty.
The wind whispered secrets through the trees: a mysterious language that made me feel like an eavesdropper in a foreign land.
The colon creates a pause, varying the rhythm and, by dividing the sentence, reflecting the separation between the narrator and the natural world.
These features can be useful in both fiction and nonfiction. In creative nonfiction, for example, you might use figurative language and imagery to make your writing engaging and immersive for the reader whilst also being informative.
Developing your voice and style
A distinctive voice is an essential aspect of effective writing. Your writing should reflect your unique perspective and personality. Finding your own style helps give your writing an authentic quality that enhances the connection between you and your reader.
Freewriting is an excellent strategy for exploring and developing your voice and style. To use this technique:
- Set a timer for ten minutes
- Choose a prompt or topic to write about
- Write continuously for the entire time without worrying about spelling, grammar and punctuation
- Read over what you have written, underlining or highlighting phrases or sentences that have a strong impact or prompt further ideas
- Use these standout phrases or sentences as inspiration to write a more focused and structured piece
- Re-read and revise your writing, focusing on developing your voice and making your style consistent
- Consider your use of language features and whether you can make better use of them
Incorporating feedback during the drafting process
Receiving feedback on your writing can be challenging, but it is a helpful and essential part of the writing process. Your first drafts will be unpolished and possibly incomplete, making it difficult to see exactly what to change and how. Feedback allows you to see your writing from another perspective and identify areas for improvement.
Asking for feedback
Think carefully about who you ask and what specifically you would like them to comment on:
- Consider the best person to give you feedback for the stage you are at. You can ask your teacher, but feedback from a classmate or family member can also be helpful.
- Explain your purpose, context and audience to the person reading your work. This helps them decide whether you are crafting your text appropriately and enables them to comment on aspects such as word choices and structure.
- Provide your reader with specific questions to answer. This makes their feedback more targeted and useful to you.
- Give your reader enough time to consider your work and think about what changes would improve it.
Using feedback effectively
Using feedback effectively will help you produce a stronger final response:
- Start by thanking the person who provided the feedback. This shows that you appreciate their time and effort.
- Read the feedback carefully and try to understand the reader's perspective.
- Consider whether the feedback is constructive and relevant to your goals. Will the suggested changes help you achieve your purpose? Are they appropriate for your intended audience?
- Prioritise the feedback by deciding which changes are essential and which ones are optional.
- Revise your draft based on the feedback, addressing the specific points raised by your reader.
- Review your revised draft and check that the feedback has been incorporated smoothly and effectively.
- Consider asking for additional feedback once you have revised your piece, either from the same person or someone different for a new perspective.
Remember: Not all feedback needs to be implemented. Consider whether the suggested changes align with your purpose and audience, and prioritise changes that will make the most significant improvements to your work.
Standard and non-standard language
In this area of study, you are encouraged to use both standard and non-standard language. Depending on what is appropriate to your form, purpose and context, you can use slang, dialects and other informal language in your writing.
When incorporating both types of language:
- Identify the purpose and audience of your response
- Consider where it might be appropriate to use non-standard language and where standard language might be more appropriate
- Experiment with using non-standard language and consider how it affects the tone and style of your response
- Seek feedback on your use of language to ensure it is appropriate for your purpose and audience
- Reflect on the feedback and revise as needed to incorporate standard and non-standard language effectively
Editing your response
Editing is a crucial step in the writing process that involves refining and improving your work. Editing takes place after you have drafted your piece and decided on form, structure and style. It is all about making your writing more effective and better targeted to its context, audience and purpose.
Peer-editing
Working with peers to edit and revise your writing can significantly improve your work. During a peer-editing workshop:
- Pair up with a peer and exchange your written pieces for editing
- Use assessment criteria (such as VCAA Performance Descriptors) to evaluate each other's responses
- Focus on identifying areas for improvement such as grammar, punctuation, word choices, sentence structures, fluency and coherence
- You might do multiple passes, using a different colour for each focus (such as yellow highlights for grammar, pink for punctuation, blue for word choices)
- Provide constructive feedback by highlighting specific areas and making suggestions for improvement
- Discuss the feedback with your partner and ask any clarifying questions
- Revise your written piece based on the feedback you received
- Swap pieces again and repeat the process, incorporating any new feedback
Using a systematic approach with multiple focused passes helps you catch different types of issues. By concentrating on one aspect at a time—such as grammar, then punctuation, then word choices—you're more likely to identify areas for improvement that might otherwise be overlooked.
Proofreading for grammar, spelling and punctuation
Proofreading is the final step in the writing process. It involves checking your work for errors in grammar, spelling and punctuation. You can also make minor changes to improve word choices, but avoid doing too much rewriting at this stage.
When proofreading:
- Correct any spelling errors. If using a computer, use a spellchecker to identify possible errors, but remember that spellcheckers are not always accurate. If your piece is handwritten, use a dictionary to double-check the spelling of any words you are uncertain of.
- Look for common errors, such as using the wrong word or confusing homophones
- Check for correct punctuation (especially apostrophe use) and capitalisation
- Read your work aloud to catch any errors you may have missed, such as missing or repeated words
Common Proofreading Pitfall: Spellcheckers can't catch every error, especially when you've used the wrong word that happens to be spelled correctly (like "their" instead of "there"). Always do a careful manual proofread in addition to using automated tools.
Writing a reflective commentary
In your reflective commentary, you will discuss the writing process and the choices made during that process. Reflecting on why you made these choices and how effective you think they were is key. Think about what was challenging, what worked and what didn't, and what could have been done differently.
What to include
Consider the following aspects of your writing when reflecting on your authorial choices:
- The purpose and audience of the response
- The form and genre you selected
- The language features you employed
- The impact of mentor texts on your writing
- The drafting and editing process and the role of feedback in shaping your decisions
Example approach
A strong reflective commentary might include:
Worked Example: Reflective Commentary Structure
Explaining your form choice: "I chose to create a podcast in the form of a series of personal reflections. I was inspired by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie's TED Talk because it has such a strong and passionate voice... I wanted to share some of my unique experiences with a broad audience, and felt that the podcast form was a great fit because it allowed me to engage with this audience in a personal and authentic way."
Discussing deliberate decisions: Include specific examples of vocabulary, text structures, language features and conventions with references to your piece.
Reflecting on revisions: "My first drafts were too serious and impersonal, so I revised my text using a more conversational tone and incorporating personal anecdotes to make my message..."
Analysing your language features
To evaluate the effectiveness of your authorial choices:
- Choose a piece of writing you have completed and read through it
- Identify the language features you have used, such as imagery, figurative language, non-standard language and different types of sentences
- Analyse the effectiveness of these features and consider how well they contribute to the meaning and impact of your writing
- Reflect on any changes you could make to improve effectiveness, such as adding more descriptive language, reducing wordiness (by deleting some adjectives and adverbs, for instance) or varying sentence structures
- Make notes on the changes you make and your reasons for making them, as you can draw on these notes when writing the reflective commentary
Key Points to Remember:
-
The writing process has five key stages: prewriting, drafting, revising, editing and publishing. Each stage is essential for creating an effective response.
-
Plan thoroughly before drafting: Use brainstorming, graphic organisers and detailed outlines to organise your ideas and establish a clear structure.
-
Use language features strategically: Incorporate imagery, figurative language, varied sentence structures and varied punctuation to make your writing engaging and memorable.
-
Seek and incorporate feedback: Feedback from teachers, peers and others provides valuable perspectives that can significantly improve your work. Be specific about what feedback you need and thoughtful about how you incorporate it.
-
Edit and proofread carefully: The editing and proofreading stages refine your work, ensuring it is polished, coherent and free from errors. These final steps can make the difference between a good response and an excellent one.