Bolshevik Consolidation, 1918–1924: Consolidation of the Communist Dictatorship (AQA A-Level History): Revision Notes

Consolidation of the One-Party State

---

Early consolidation measures

During the first months of 1918, Sovnarkom issued a series of decrees that simultaneously addressed practical problems and advanced the construction of a socialist state. These measures affected economic organisation, military structure, and the relationship between religion and the state.

Worker control and economic restructuring

In January 1918, workers were placed in charge of the railways. This decree served multiple purposes: it fulfilled Bolshevik promises about worker control of industry, it addressed the practical need to maintain the transport system, and it helped remove the Social Revolutionaries' appeal to railway workers, who had traditionally supported that party.

The government also moved to abolish private land ownership. Land was given "to those who wish to cultivate it not for personal profit but for the benefit of the community." This policy of socialisation of land represented the programme long advocated by the Social Revolutionaries. By implementing it, the Bolsheviks simultaneously fulfilled their land decree promises and undermined their rivals' distinctive appeal.

Military reorganisation

The old Red Guards were demobilised and replaced by a new professional force. The Red Guards had been volunteer workers who helped carry out the October Revolution, but they lacked military discipline and training. In January 1918, a Red Army of workers and peasants was formed to protect the regime. Trotsky was placed at the head of this army in March 1918, giving him control over what would become the Bolsheviks' most powerful instrument of coercion. The capital was simultaneously transferred from Petrograd to Moscow, providing a more central and defensible location for the government.

Church and state separation

The Bolsheviks moved decisively against the institutional power of the Orthodox Church. Church and State were formally separated, and although religious belief was not banned outright, Russia became a secular state with the government offering no support to the Orthodox Church. The separation decree removed the Church's judicial powers and its right to own property, and many of its assets were seized.

Religious printing presses were closed down and the clergy were disenfranchised, deprived of civil rights and subjected to persecution. Some priests were drafted into the Red Army, others faced imprisonment. This campaign served multiple functions: it struck at a traditionally conservative institution that might oppose Bolshevik rule, it provided property and resources for the state, and it demonstrated the regime's commitment to materialist ideology.

Calendar reform

Russia's adoption of the Gregorian calendar in February 1918 brought the country into alignment with most of the rest of Europe. This practical measure also carried symbolic weight as a statement against traditional religious practice, since the old Julian calendar had been closely associated with Orthodox Church festivals and observances.

The 1918 Constitution

To oversee Russia's transition to a socialist society, the first Soviet Constitution for the Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic (RSFSR) was proclaimed in July 1918. This document stated that supreme power rested with the All-Russian Congress of Soviets, composed of deputies from elected local soviets across Russia. The Central Executive Committee of that Congress was designated the "supreme organ of power," functioning like a president. The Congress was also made responsible for electing Sovnarkom for purposes of the general administration of state affairs.

Democratic appearance

On paper, the new constitution appeared to establish democratic governance. Local communities would elect soviet representatives, these soviets would send delegates to the national Congress, and the Congress would control the executive. This structure suggested popular sovereignty and accountability.

Limitations and reality

The constitution's democratic appearance masked several restrictions that concentrated power in Bolshevik hands:

First, the vote was reserved for the "toiling masses." Members of the former exploiting classes—which included businessmen, clergy and tsarist officials—were excluded from voting or holding public office. This provision eliminated from political participation precisely those social groups most likely to oppose Bolshevik policies.

Second, the workers' vote was weighted in the proportion of five to one against that of the peasants in elections to the All-Russian Congress of Soviets. Since workers concentrated in cities were more likely to support the Bolsheviks, while peasants remained more conservative and sympathetic to the Social Revolutionaries, this weighting ensured urban Bolshevik dominance over the more numerous but geographically dispersed rural population.

Third, although Sovnarkom was officially appointed by the Congress, in practice it was chosen by the Communist Party's Central Committee. The Congress, therefore, rubber-stamped decisions already made by the party leadership.

Fourth, the Congress met only at intervals, leaving executive authority continuously in Sovnarkom's hands during the gaps between sessions. This meant day-to-day governance remained with Lenin's government rather than with the supposedly supreme representative body.

Fifth, the structure was centralised, with the real focus of power residing in the Party rather than in the constitutional organs. The Communist Party Central Committee controlled Sovnarkom, and party discipline ensured compliance throughout the system.

These limitations reveal that the 1918 Constitution established a framework of control rather than genuine democracy. Formal structures masked the reality of single-party dictatorship.

Additional consolidation measures

Beyond the formal constitutional structure, the Bolsheviks implemented policies that further tightened their grip on society.

The principle was established that "he who does not work shall not eat." This represented a serious threat in Russia's dire economic circumstances, when much of the population depended on ration cards for food. The policy allowed the regime to control access to basic necessities and punish those deemed unproductive or politically unreliable.

The constitution welcomed the non-Russian nationalities that had been part of the old Russian Empire into the new Soviet state. This appeared generous, but proved problematic in practice. Many people among these national groups did not want to be part of a Russian-controlled state, regardless of its ideological character. The extent to which they should be forced to join the new confederation became a source of friction among the leading Bolsheviks themselves, with different views about how much autonomy to permit versus how much central control to impose.