The Falklands (AQA A-Level History): Revision Notes
The Falklands
The Falkland Islands had previously attracted little attention. However, the Falklands War came to dominate British foreign policy in the early 1980s. In the longer view of history, the conflict was a relatively minor episode in Britain’s retreat from empire. Britain’s international position was shaped more by relations with Europe and developments in the Cold War.
Background to the conflict
The Falkland Islands lie 300 miles east of the South American mainland. Britain had maintained sovereignty over the territory since 1833, when it established both a colony and naval base there. Argentina contested this ownership, referring to the islands as Las Malvinas and basing territorial claims on Spanish colonial possessions prior to Argentine independence in 1817.
By the 1970s, the Falklands held minimal strategic value for Britain. The islands' remote location and small population meant that Foreign Office officials were prepared to enter negotiations with Argentina regarding their future status.
The approximately 1,800 islanders, however, consistently expressed their preference to remain under British rule rather than accept Argentine sovereignty.
The withdrawal of HMS Endurance
In 1981, Foreign Secretary Lord Carrington and Defence Secretary John Nott approved the withdrawal of HMS Endurance, the sole British naval vessel stationed in the South Atlantic. This decision proved to have unintended diplomatic consequences.
Lord Carrington's Background
Lord Carrington had inherited his seat in the House of Lords in 1938 at age 19. He served as Defence Secretary in Edward Heath's government before becoming Foreign Secretary in 1979 under Thatcher. His experience in foreign affairs made his subsequent resignation over the Falklands particularly notable.
Argentina's military junta, which had controlled the country since 1976, interpreted the removal of HMS Endurance as a signal that Britain was willing to relinquish the Falklands. The junta's leader, General Galtieri, concluded that Britain lacked both the capability and determination to defend the islands militarily.
The Argentine invasion
Acting on this assumption, Galtieri ordered Argentine forces to invade and occupy the Falklands in April 1982, asserting Argentine sovereignty over Las Malvinas.
What is a Junta?
A junta refers to a military group that seizes control of a country through force rather than democratic processes. The Argentine junta faced domestic economic problems and saw the Falklands operation as a means to rally nationalist sentiment and consolidate power.
The invasion placed the British government in an awkward position. Recapturing the islands through military force would be extremely difficult and dangerous, given the 8,000-mile distance from Britain. Yet the government had already demonstrated its willingness to negotiate over the islands' future, suggesting military action might be unnecessary.
Lord Carrington resigned following the invasion. His resignation was particularly principled because he had actually advised against withdrawing HMS Endurance, but had been overruled by cabinet colleagues. His departure signaled the seriousness of the situation and the government's acceptance of responsibility for the policy failure.
Thatcher's response
Despite the considerable risks involved, Thatcher's response was immediate and unequivocal: she announced that a naval task force would be dispatched to remove Argentine forces and restore the islanders' right to self-determination.
A Massive Political Gamble
This decision represented an enormous political gamble. Public opinion polls showed Thatcher's government was deeply unpopular before the conflict. A military disaster comparable to the 1956 Suez Crisis could have destroyed her premiership entirely.
The patriotic mood that swept Britain took many observers by surprise, including television journalists reporting from the scene. The American magazine Newsweek captured this sentiment with its headline "The Empire Strikes Back".
The military campaign
Although Britain had committed to military action, diplomatic efforts continued in an attempt to persuade Argentina to withdraw its forces peacefully. On 2 May 1982, the last realistic opportunity for a negotiated settlement disappeared when a British submarine sank the Argentine battleship General Belgrano, causing substantial loss of life.
The Belgrano Controversy
The sinking of the Belgrano generated considerable controversy. The vessel was heading away from the designated battle zone when it was torpedoed, leading critics to argue that the attack was unnecessary and deliberately designed to eliminate any possibility of a peaceful resolution.
The tabloid newspaper The Sun published the headline "GOTCHA!" the following day, reflecting a triumphalist attitude that many found distasteful. Anti-war protesters maintained that the sinking revealed the government's determination to pursue military victory regardless of opportunities for negotiation.
American support
Fighting a war 8,000 miles from home would have been impossible without access to American military bases. The United States allowed Britain to use Ascension Island as a staging post for the naval task force.
The Special Relationship in Action
Unlike the 1956 Suez Crisis, when American opposition had forced Britain to abandon its military operation, the United States under President Reagan gave Britain the diplomatic green light to proceed. This support strengthened both the special relationship between Britain and the United States and the personal connection between Thatcher and Reagan.
American diplomatic intervention proved decisive at several points during the conflict. On 4 May, an air-launched Exocet missile destroyed HMS Sheffield, demonstrating Argentina's capacity to inflict serious damage on British forces. American officials prevented Argentina from acquiring additional Exocet missiles that could have severely weakened the British task force and potentially changed the outcome of the war.
British victory
On 21 May, British troops successfully landed at San Carlos Water. The passage between East and West Falkland was secured, and from that point British victory became increasingly certain. Argentine forces surrendered on 14 June 1982, just over ten weeks after the invasion.
The conflict had been close-run despite the eventual clear outcome. British forces suffered losses including the destruction of HMS Sheffield and other vessels. The speed of the Argentine collapse surprised some observers, given the distances involved and the challenges of mounting an amphibious assault.
Domestic political impact
Thatcher delivered a speech at a Conservative rally in Cheltenham in June 1982 following the victory. She declared:
"We have ceased to be a nation in retreat. We have instead a newfound confidence – born in the economic battles at home and tested and found true 8000 miles away."
The speech emphasized that Britain had "rekindled that spirit which has fired her for generations past" and had proven itself again in the South Atlantic.
Transformation of Public Opinion
The conflict transformed public opinion dramatically. Thatcher's government, which had been deeply unpopular due to economic policies and rising unemployment, experienced a surge in support. The patriotic national mood extended across much of society. This resurgence of national pride marked a psychological shift after decades during which Britain's international standing had appeared to decline.
Debate over significance
Thatcher's critics argued that the war was unnecessary because Britain would eventually have negotiated a settlement with Argentina over the Falklands anyway. They questioned whether the loss of life was justified for territories that had limited strategic importance.
The psychological impact, however, extended beyond simple military victory. Britain's international position had seemed to be in decline throughout the 1970s. The successful recapture of the Falklands provided evidence that Britain could still project military power globally when necessary.
Mixed Public Response
Not everyone embraced this interpretation. Some Britons objected to the triumphalist tone adopted by tabloid newspapers and politicians, feeling that the celebration resembled inappropriate gloating rather than measured satisfaction. Critics argued that treating the conflict as though it were comparable to the Second World War was both historically inaccurate and morally questionable.
Long-term consequences
The impact on Britain's foreign position remained ambiguous. In the broader context of world affairs, the Falklands War was essentially a stand-alone event. It did not halt the continuing process of decolonization or significantly alter Britain's international relationships beyond the immediate participants.
The conflict did make it less probable that Britain would agree to transfer Gibraltar to Spain. The demonstration that Britain would defend territories whose populations wished to remain British strengthened the position of Gibraltarians who resisted Spanish sovereignty claims.
Diplomatic relations with Argentina eventually resumed in 1989, indicating that the conflict had not created permanent animosity between the two nations. Overall, while the war had substantial domestic political consequences for Thatcher's government, it represented merely a minor episode in international affairs rather than a turning point in British foreign policy.
The Falklands remained a source of tension between Britain and Argentina. In the 1980s, Britain still maintained various territories worldwide as remnants of its imperial past. The Falkland Islands exemplified this legacy. Gibraltar, a British territory since the early eighteenth century at the southern end of the Iberian peninsula, continued to be claimed by Spain, though Gibraltarians repeatedly confirmed their preference to remain British. Hong Kong, which became a British colony in the nineteenth century, was scheduled for return to China under the 1984 Sino-British Declaration, with the actual handover occurring in 1997.
Key Points to Remember:
-
The Falkland Islands, a British colony since 1833 located 300 miles from South America, were invaded by Argentina's military junta in April 1982 after Britain withdrew HMS Endurance, signaling potential willingness to negotiate sovereignty.
-
Thatcher's immediate decision to dispatch a naval task force represented a substantial political gamble that transformed her government's popularity and restored British national confidence after decades of perceived decline.
-
The controversial sinking of the General Belgrano on 2 May eliminated prospects for peaceful settlement, while American support through access to Ascension Island and diplomatic intervention proved essential to British victory on 14 June.
-
The conflict generated debate between those who celebrated renewed British military capability and national pride versus critics who objected to triumphalism and questioned the necessity of war for territories with limited strategic importance.
-
While the Falklands War had profound domestic political consequences for Thatcher, it remained a relatively minor episode in international affairs, with diplomatic relations between Britain and Argentina resuming by 1989.